A little while back, io9er Ed said Titan was "The Awesomest Moon in the Solar System." Well where I come from, them's fightin' words. What about Earth's Moon? Mars' Phobos? Europa?? There are boatloads of kickass moons in the solar system. We break down ten contenders in a highly scientific chart to settle this debate, once and for all.
Crowning a moon champion ain't as easy as it seems when Saturn alone has 59 of them. Fortunately the field got smaller when we considered five key points all moons should have on their resumes. It may be hard to stomach having Charon up there — it's questionable that it's even a moon — but someone had to be the goat.

And now, the winners in the individual categories:
BEST FEATURE NAME: Despite tons of creative feature names, Europa wins by a wide margin with Rathmore Chaos. It sounds like a level of Hell from Dante's Inferno, but like most of the outer system, the Chaos is a cold place. In fact it's a jumble of broken up ice that's evidence of the moon's active ice tectonics...and maybe a liquid water ocean below.
POTENTIAL FOR COLONIZATION: Phobos gave Earth's Luna a run for it's money; it's low gravity and proximity to the Red Planet make it worthy of it's full score. But in the end the deck's stacked against the Martian moon — the stated goal for NASA's next generation of manned spaceflight is to return to the moon...to stay.
ACTIVE GEOLOGY: This is a toughy. Uranus' moon Miranda doesn't have active geology, but scientists speculate that the whole moon may have been obliterated by impacts, then reassembled itself. You know, like T-1000 in Terminator 2. Charon, Triton, and Enceladus all look like they've got actively erupting cryovolcanoes of frigid ammonia, water, or liquid nitrogen which is cool, but it knocks Titan down a notch in uniqueness. Jupiter's Io wins for it's self sacrifice though; riddled with volcanoes, the firey moon is literally gutting itself, spewing 1 ton of sulfur dioxide into space every second.
MOVIE/BOOK: The hands-down winner is Earth's Moon, which has been in books and movies since the art forms were invented. It's hardly a fair fight, so the prize goes to Jupiter's Ganymede. The largest moon in the solar system (that's right, bigger than Titan!), it haunts tons of Philip K. Dick's books.
POTENTIAL FOR LIFE: Cryovolcanoes are going off all over the solar system's icy moons, and where there are volcanoes, there's liquid. Most of the liquid is in the form of methane, ammonia, nitrogen, or some other substance that Earth-life wouldn't want to swim in, but who knows what sort of strange aliens could be out there?
That said, Europa's icy shell is made of old-fashioned H2O, and features like Rathmore Chaos look a lot like shifting pack ice here on Earth, which floats on a big ocean of salty water, which in turn contains tons of critters. There's a good chance the same is true on Europa, meaning....
the prize for THE OVERALL AWESOMEST MOON IN THE SOLAR SYSTEM goes to EUROPA!!! Honorable mention to TItan for a strong showing, but it just goes to show...don't mess with the moon with the water oceans under the ice!
Sources: Lunar and Planetary Institute













Comments
ALL THESE WORLDS ARE YOURS, EXCEPT EUROPA.
ATTEMPT NO LANDING THERE.
USE THEM TOGETHER. USE THEM IN PEACE.
That's no moon....
io9... um, I mean... Io is lame.
Aw, come on. Charon wins for its sheer size. It's half the size of Pluto!
@Belabras: It's a small body in an irregular orbit around another mass.
(it's too big to be a space station)
Hehe that was cool/interesting...
I guess you colonize the moon you have, not the moon you wish you had...
@twophrasebark: Those monoliths sure are buzz killers. Don't invite them to parties.
@mechtroid: Pluto isn't exactly giant in the first place though, is it?
Bah! How about Dactyl?
I still think Ganymede is the best.
@Annalee Newitz: Really? Ganymede, after they totally blew the 2213 World Series of Space-Ball? Bah. Now I'm rooting for Phobos
Phobos is going to crash into Mars sooner rather than later. How much effort do we really want to put into it?
And where's our Europa probe, dammit!
Io wins the equivalent of Miss Congeniality -- The Best Moon Without A Consonant Award.
@Fwiffo: I was at a wedding reception that this totally drunk Monolith crashed. It was all like:
"ALL THESE HORS D'OEUVRES ARE YOURS, EXCEPT THE CRAB PUFFS.
ATTEMPT NO SNACKING THERE.
EAT THEM TOGETHER. EAT THEM IN PEACE."
What a dick.
And hey, dont pick on Charon so much-- it has a *great* personality.
@Grey_Area: Well, those crab puffs were something wonderful!
No Mimas?
Shafted!
@Grey_Area: That... that was just full of Win, right there. nice job.
Aw shucks...
[blushes]
Surely Phobos and Deimos get something for having all those imps and demons and spider monsters?
You mean it was all in vain??
Why no love for Enceladus? You've got to love the Tiger Stripes.
Europa, I always knew it was the coolest. seriously.
@tyr540: Enceladus is totally overrated just because it squirts.
@Fwiffo:
HAL-9000: What is going to happen?
Dave: Something wonderful.
HAL-9000: I'm afraid.
Dave: Don't be. We'll be together.
HAL-9000: Where will we be?
Dave: Where I am now.
And now a never before released made-up deleted scene:
HAL-9000: No. Seriously. Where?
Dave: It's just wonderful.
HAL-9000: Did they like, remove some of your brain cells or something?
Dave: it's all very clear to me now. The whole thing. It's wonderful.
HAL-9000: Yeah, I got that. Um, thanks. Thanks for that.
@twophrasebark: HAL-9000: Did they like, remove some of your brain cells or something?
HAL saying that to Dave.. that would be ironic!
Ow, I just got my ass handed to me in a moon fight.
On the positive side, I now have a name for my new band.
Rathmore Chaos.
@Annalee Newitz: Moon jiz!!
How does Mimas not even get mentioned???? My favoritest moon of all time. It's the Death Star, how do you beat that??
Call me an old fashioned girl but my heart belongs to Luna.
But Charon and Pluto are tidally locked: a planet to moon elevator could be a possibility.
@Ed Grabianowski: My band Stickney is going to kick your band's ass.
[upload.wikimedia.org]
What a timely post. How did you know I've thinking about the moons lately and wanted to hear more about them? Thank the staff telepaths for me, io9.
This post could definitely have used more pictures, though. Another point in Europa's favor is that it's very pretty.
Not sure why that's showing a link instead of a picture...it worked in the preview...
*scratches head*
Charon should win the name thing. Its named after the god damn boatman after all.
That or NIX, Pluto's other moon (Or technically, the "pluto/charon binary dwarf planets"' moon). She's named after the goddess of all darkness.
Our Moon wins because it's so beautiful and it's ours. Second place might go to Io, just because it's got some great color.
@mechtroid: but Pluto is about the same size as our moon!
As far as I'm concerned, there is only one moon, and that is the American moon, and all the rest of you pinkos can go to hell while the rest of us normal folk have some apple pie with your grandmas at a baseball game!
Forget these moons, it's all about 1 Ceres. It's a giant, spherical asteroid / dwarf planet with a probable ocean of water and a tenuous oxogen atmosphere. It's not warm - only up to -30F - but still. It's got more potential than most of these other pretenders.
1 Ceres. The number goes before the name - that's how ill it is. It's actually an MFf'ing dwarf planet. Moons suck. Phobos? C'mon. Google 1 Ceres.
I don't know, Titan gets some points for having an atmosphere and weather...
-Kle.
@moff: "I for one don't wish to go to sleep by the light of a Communist Moon!"
I love The Right Stuff.
I call shenanigans.
You have to give bonus points to Titan (and Triton, I suppose) for 'likelihood of life that makes those deep sea creatures look like fluffy bunnies'.
FYI, the odds of our moon being the exact right size... and right distance from the Earth... in order to appear the same size as the sun and be able to perfectly eclipse it...
...is basically zero. It happens on no other planet in our system and you could probably spend eternity trying to find such an occurrence in another system.
We take it for granted, as for granted as, well, the sun and the moon. But ask any astronomer.
Let's just say, it sort of raises some questions.
Hell yeah Europa! Definitely the best!
(I knew I named my laptop Europa for a reason!)
@twophrasebark: Actually this happens with several other planets and moons in our own solar system. Specifically with Saturn and Epimetheus; cf Saturnian eclipse.
Oh come on. How are we even debating this.
Arthur C. Clarke said it was Europa, ergo it was Europa.
Does there really need to be any further conversation on the topic?
I remember when Sputnik first went up (well actually I don't, but I remember reading about when it first went up) and the media were talking about it as a 'new moon' or 'red moon'. So nuts to your moons of ice and fire, my vote goes to the only moon that goes 'beep'.
And anyway, wouldn't that there theoretical mass-extinctionizing Nemesis the Death Star technically be a moon of the Sun and therefore the hands-down winner here? All those other moons (even the ones that go 'beep') may be great but have they ever killed themselves a whole mess of dinosaurs?
As an alternative look at of some of these moons, try digging out copies of Activisions Battlezone's 1 & 2 for the pc.
Given their age, I still think they look fantastic, and they at least try to get the science right, whilst allowing you to wage a covert cold war of course.
I think I'll reinstall those now actually...
wow, a reference to the late 90s battlezone remakes... anyway, no Charon? Besides having the coolest name, I think Cerebus the Aardvark was stranded there.
Too bad we couldn't bury Clarke on Europa. That would have been fitting.
@twophrasebark: Not as many as whatever you're implying.
Charon and its inhabitants are center stage in Varley's "The Golden Globe". Add the book to your list!
@jakel: Huh? The article doesn't say that.
"In fact, the Epimetheus is only about 30% bigger than the Sun, so it wouldn't be [b]that much different[/b] than a solar eclipse on Earth, where the Moon and Sun are almost the same size in the sky."
Emphasis mine. I mean, if you're far enough way, I guess you can make a lot of arguments that "it's not that different" because you are looking at a tiny dot and another tiny dot. But it seems like kind of a cheap argument to me.
@noncornbatant: What? Don't understand your comment.
Charon got totally robbed here - it has no named features because it's so hella far away that we can hardly see it. It's mysteeeerious. Plus I love the fact that you could build a bridge between Charon and Pluto.
I pick Ariel (named for the sprite in Shakespeare's The Tempest).
Mostly because it shares that name with my daughter (also named for said spirit). :-)
Comment on this post
Reply by EmailLogin with your username and password below. Or comment on this post via email.
Forgot your username or password? New User?