SAN FRANCISCO, 10:02 AM, WED JUL 9 | 29 POSTS IN THE LAST 24 HOURS | tips@io9.com | RSS

Science Fiction Is The Literature Of Refugees

When you think about the archetypal science fiction story, chances are you think of the bold explorer, setting foot on a newfound planet in the name of a secure homeworld. But possibly the most pervasive narrative in science fiction is actually the story of refugees. They flee from planetary destruction, war, or just from overcrowding and ecological crappitude. The refugee story is the flipside of the gung-ho explorer story, but it might actually be the most uniquely science fictional story of all.

The alien visitor from a doomed world:

Hsuperman.jpgThe most famous refugee in science fiction is probably Superman, who gets sent to safety when his home planet Krypton is destroyed. It's no coincidence that Superman is also the posterboy for assimilation — his "real" family is the Kents of Kansas, and he thinks of himself as an American. He gets to live the refugee's dream, being totally accepted into a prosperous new world — plus he's physically and mentally superior to everyone else around him, which is a plus. He's the embodiment of the melting pot, even as he has the power to melt you. (And of course, his creators Siegel & Schuster were the sons of poor Jewish immigrants from Eastern Europe, mainly Lithuania and Ukraine.)

Doctor Who, meanwhile, has the same alien-world story as Superman, but without the assimilation. The Doctor, in the early episodes from 1963, drops hints about being on the run and in hiding, but doesn't explain further. The show's creators had a vague sense, originally, that he was fleeing a space war. But by the time it's explained in 1969, the explanation is much more benign: the Doctor's species are dicks. (No, not Terrance Dicks. Just dicks.) It's not until the show's 42nd birthday that we get back to the idea that he's fleeing a space war (upgraded to a time war.) And his planet has been destroyed, just like Superman's. But like I mentioned, he doesn't assimilate with Earth/British culture — even though he constantly takes on weird British affectations like jelly babies or cricket, they only make him seem like more of an outsider. He's like those Indian immigrants in the TV show Goodness Gracious Me, who anglicize their names and try to be more British than everyone else, only to look more out of place than ever. In many ways, the Doctor is the anti-Superman.

The protagonist who's fleeing war or genocide:

There are also tons of characters who flee a doomed or destroyed Earth, including Arthur Dent in the Hitchhiker's Guide To The Galaxy series. And John Varley's novels frequently take place in a universe where humans have been forced to flee an Earth invaded by aliens, and have colonized the rest of the solar system as a result.

And then there's Hope Hubris, the hero of Piers Anthony's Bio Of A Space Tyrant series. As the first book's title, Refugee, suggests, Hubris starts out as a humble refugee from the moon Callisto, fleeing to Jupiter, where his family gets killed horribly. This starts him on his path towards becoming the "Tyrant of Jupiter."

The rag-tag fleet of humans:

And then there are plenty of stories in which a straggling mob of people flees from a disaster or massacre in space. Maybe the most critically acclaimed SF show right now — if not the most popular — is Battlestar Galactica, where the Cylons drive the humans out of their homeworld not once, but twice: on Caprica, and then on New Caprica. At the end of season three, Lee Adama makes a huge speech in which he says this has changed humanity from a civilization to a "gang," on the run and doing whatever it takes to survive.

Less organized rabbles also turn up, fleeing wars or political unrest, in books like C.J. Cherryh's Downbelow Station, where swarms of refugees pack into Pell Station in the wake of conflict between the Earth Company and outer stations. And a mob of refugees from a disaster that befalls the H9 colony swarms aboard a cruise ship, only to be exploited by the media, in Eric Idle's The Road To Mars. The TV show Babylon 5 is also full of refugee crises, like the people fleeing the Vorlon attack on Ventari III in "Falling Towards Apotheosis." (We also see a ship full of refugees under attack in the first regular episode, "Midnght On The Firing Line.")

Eco-refugees or disaster survivors on Earth:

Every eco-disaster narrative or post-apocalyptic story includes some kind of refugee motif, with people fleeing the destroyed cities or trying to find a safe haven. Like The Day After Tomorrow, The Postman, Waterworld, or Mad Max. Or Steven Gould's novel Blind Waves. The Martian attacks in War Of The Worlds spawn a huge fleet of refugee ships running away from the carnage. Islanders flee rising sea levels, only to drown or wind up in horrible refugee boat camps, in the 2002 young adult novel Exodus. And of course, there are tons of refugees from the collapsing nations of the world, seeking sanctuary in the U.K., in Children Of Men. Not to mention the Raft of refugees organized by telecommunications magnate L. Bob Rife in Neal Stephenson's Snow Crash.

One of the most arresting moments in the TV show Jericho is when our heroes find the remains of a refugee train a mile wide, made by people fleeing the frozen north. The refugees have left their icy dead where they lay. (Not to mention the whole gaggle of refugees who settle in Jericho, only to face expulsion again.)

Survivalists:

And the survivalist narrative is a huge part of science fiction. Robert Heinlein not only wrote the novel Farnham's Freehold, about people surviving a nuclear war, but according to the source of all lies, he also wrote "How To Be A Survivor" and other essays on surviving nuclear war. Frederik Pohl deals with similar themes in his story "Fermi And Frost." Also, Larry Niven and Jerry Pournelle write about a group of survivors barricading themselves into a mountain retreat after a deadly comet strike, in Lucifer's Hammer. Plus there's The Survivors, the TV show Terry Nation made between his work on Doctor Who and Blake's 7 (which is also a refugee show, sort of.)

And then there are the narratives about people going on the run from repressive regimes. Like Logan's Run, where Logan flees the non-stop beautiful-people orgy where they kill you when you reach 30, in search of the mythical Sanctuary. (And in the Logan's Run TV series, he's just on the run, every week, with a rogue android. In Roger McBride Allen's The Ring Of Charon, Marcia MacDougal can only escape from the repressive Naked Purple movement, which has taken over a lunar penal colony, by being declared a refugee when her house burns down.

Fleeing from the future:

And finally there are refugees in time — sort of like the Doctor, except they're fleeing a particular oppressive future through time travel. Just type "refugee from the future" into Google (with the quotation marks) and you get a bunch of weird stories — including various X-Men who have journeyed back to our time to escape one of those Mutants-in-concentration-camps dystopian futures.

I feel as though I've just scratched the surface of science fiction's nearly endless store of refugees here — this post could be twice as long. But these seem to be the main types of refugees in science fiction, and I was somewhat surprised by how many of them I turned up when I started looking.

History is full of mass evacuations and displacements, and we've gotten pretty used to the sight of streams of humans struggling across an unforgiving landscape with whatever they can carry, trying to escape from something or other. But it seems pretty likely the 21st century will see more refugee crises than ever before, as the number of humans on the planet continues to skyrocket and there are more ecological disasters and wars over scarce resources. There will be more and more refugees — possibly including you.

And science fiction is uniquely suited to tell the stories of these fleeing people, because the stark reality of the refugee condition is so awful, we need metaphors to cover it. It's easier to think about people running away from an exploding planet than it is to think about grabbing what you can and running from your home before you get ethnically cleansed. A dollop of escapism — or, in the case of Superman, a truckload — helps us swallow the unthinkable.

Note: The illustration up top comes from Wagner James Au's New World Notes blog, from a report about a virtual "Camp Darfur" in Second Life, which was being vandalized by asswipes spouting racist slogans. So a team of Green Lanterns, most of them extraterrestrial, took it upon themselves to guard the site.

5:00 PM on Fri May 16 2008
By Charlie Jane Anders
3,990 views
24 comments

Comments

  • How about folks with special abilities who have to run and hide from the scientists who would turn them into lab rats, or from a government (or criminal agency) who would use them against their will for nefarious ends. Various incarnations of the X-Men. Witch Mountain, anyone?

    I'm reminded of the Nancy Kress Beggars trilogy...though perhaps the super-sleepless are not refugees so much as exiles of the self-imposed variety...

  • This is a great post, but the the note about Second Life might be my favourite part...real life, imagination, and science fiction all intersecting around the refugee.

  • Anyone remember a book by Andrew J. Offutt called The Galactic Rejects? The protagonists are running from a war. They were being used by their regime for their various powers of telepathy, telekinesis, and teleportation and go into hiding on a relatively low-tech world where they, if I remember correctly, join a carnival...

    Also, good post indeed, Charlie.

  • I think these types of stories might be very popular with SF fans and writers because so many of us feel alienated (ugh, a pun) maybe even persecuted by whatever passes for the mainstream.
    I would never equate the horrors of Darfur with getting stuffed into a school locker in Middle School* but it may make some of us pathetic types more sympathetic to people who are Really living as outsiders. Just a thought.
    Anyhoo, I'm signing off to quaff some brews with my nerdy bretheren. Cheers!

    *eight times for me. I still get a bit nervous around lockers

  • And don't forget the colony worlds founded by refugees from Earth from Andre Norton's Peacemen of Pax (those were the bad guys) to all of Vance's myriad lost and found colonies, including whole sectors of space. I don't know of anyone who had more fun with the idea than Vance.

    The most recent one i have read was "Hunter's Run," by George R.R. Martin, Gardner Dozois and Daniel Abraham. Elizabeth Bear's Carnival had worlds settled by political refugees, if i remember correctly.

    You mention Varley, it might have been a more common meme in older stuff, with the post-WWII examples of the Jews in Israel and the Displaced Persons in America as constant reminders.

    Pretty much a standard way of populating a given world with an identifiable out-group, very useful in political satire.

  • This is a very good post, but I would raise the Postman as a perennial example of refugee sci-fi. He not only comes from a distant, ruined place, but he uses his origins to... well, that would be spoiling, but suffice to say it's important.

  • Image of Torley Torley at 07:55 PM on 05/16/08 *

    I really like the Second Life nod too! Great intro image; intriguingly, if I'm not mistaken, the blue-cast skin that avatar is wearing is a *Drow* one, modified to look more alien. So perhaps there's hope for an AD&D-DC (almost sounds like a classic rock band ;) ) crossover after all.

  • Nitpick: in "Logan's Run" the movie, you got whacked at 30, not 35. In the book, it was 21(!)

  • Heinlein also gave us "Methuselahs Children," where the very long lived "Howard Families" escaped in the first interstellar colonization craft, to avoid being imprisoned and tortured so the normals could find out their secret of long life.

    I think Lexx would qualify, as well. Nor should we forget Mel Brooks' "Jews in Space!" from "History of the World Pt. 1." OK, that one's a stretch.

  • @Evil Tortie's Mom: D'oh! I meant to check that, but my internet connection was acting up. Thanks for the save!

  • @TheAlmanac: @galatea2.2: Thanks, I'm glad you liked it! That made my evening!

  • @RAHfanboy: Oh, you beat me to it! Also, Lazarus Long might have said in Time Enough for Love that eventually all cultures schism and the best way to deal with people you don't get along with is to find your own planet. Or something like that. Heinlein seems to have had a deep appreciation for privacy. I think human sprawl throughout the Universe will simply be a result of our intense dislike for members of our own species. Go figure.

  • Image of DaiMacculate DaiMacculate at 07:39 AM on 05/17/08 *

    You did miss one of my favorites among these types of Sci Fi, AC Clark's "Songs of Distant Earth," but its an understandable omission given that the "refugee" situation there is a bit less dramatic than most of your examples.

    Also, you might want to mention the Iliad and the Aeneid, given that they more or less created and gave archetypes to the type of fiction you're describing here, but thats just a contextualization nit, not a major problem.

    All in all, excellent read and you've given me a couple of things to check out, thanks!

  • As everyone is noting, there are indeed many books featuring refugees, diaspora, or cultural dispersion in space (or occasionally time). Eric Frank Russel's The Great Explosion is one older example.

  • Eh... conflict is the essence of drama, and who is more conflicted than refugees? You're talking about people who (1) have other people that want to kill them, (2) have to battle the elements simply to survive, (3) each have their own agendas vis-a-vis where they're fleeing TO, and (4) are forced to take on the universe with little more than a spork and bad attitude.

    It's little wonder that so much fiction revolves around such people, sci-fi or otherwise. I don't think science fiction has a special monopoly on this genre.

    That being said, it's arguable that science fiction does it better, simply on the scale that it portrays. The more to be won or lost, the more important the conflict.

  • Gotta agree, an astute analysis, Charlie. Thanks.

    Perhaps its a theme that resonates so well because displacement - migration - diaspora has been a strong factor in the human experience or condition, probably since there was such a thing as a human condition.

    Just think, how many generations do you need to go back into your heritage before you find ancestors who were refugees? I'm only 1 gen away, how about you?

  • Best refugee movie moment: In "Day after Tomorrow", the scene of American refugees flooding across Mexico border to escape the cold. Ohh the irony!

  • I'm not sure if this also fits into refugee theme but there is a lot of stories about outcasts, pariahs, and people who are escaping from an antagonistic authority.

  • Parenthetically, I much preferred Rachael Grey-Summers aka Phoenix II with the butch haircut (plus the braid) and the spiked fetish outfit. Between her and The Hellfire Club you get the impression Claremont or Byrne were into some kinky shit. That version above is so family-friendly I want to ralph, if the presence of Omega Red didn't already do the trick.

  • I could be bounded in a nutshell and count myself a king of infinite space, were it not that I have bad dreams.

  • I have to say it's simple as this:

    1.) Refugees are on the run = underdog champ
    2.) Refugees have something to rally against to bring about change = revolution necessitating bravery / heroism
    3.) Refugee protagonist usually succeeds = gets cool outfit, gets girl, finds identity as leader of new world order

    Pretty cool story considering that in reality, the majority of us feel helpless as an exposed grub in an open field of hungry songbirds.

    Darfur, earthquakes, government, unaffordable health care, expensive college, terrorism, crazy wars - shit, how can you not want to be that hero who rises up and saves the world?

  • It's worth noting that a lot of these SF tropes about fleeing and refugees have even older literary and historical traditions that they're redressing. For instance, Galactica is essentially (And deliberately) a re-telling of the Biblical story of the Exodus. The Modern Galactica has re-spun it again to be an extended 9-11/War on Terror allegory. Neat stuff.

  • Interesting points. In contrast with the portrait of Superman as refugee, I'd speculate on Batman as an example of Joyce's prescription for the artist (as a young, or any sort of, man): "silence [his secrets: origin and identity], exile [he removes himself from home for an indeterminate time and, upon his return, remains alienated by his strange habits, questionable methods and occult purposes] and cunning [the world's greatest detective, saying little, seeing everything and everything behind everything]."

  • More Heinlein-- all the Lazarus Long books had to do with being a refugee.

Start a discussion:

Reply by Email

Login with your username and password below. Or comment on this post via email.