What's The Difference Between Denouement And Picking At A Scab?S

So your space-wizard novel has resolved its epic storyline: Your hero has defeated your villain, or your central mystery's been solved. But unlike your hero, your work isn't done: there's still the denouement, where we find out what happens afterwards.

It's another outing of Free Advice for Struggling Writers, our semi-regular writing advice column, in which free advice could cost you... your sanity. Or more likely, ten whole precious minutes.

I was thinking about denouements a lot, after the ongoing debate over Dumbledore's funeral in Harry Potter And The Half-Blood Prince. The story's main action wraps up with the showdown between Harry, Dumbledore, Snape and Draco... do we need to see Albus going in the ground afterwards? Do we need the closure? Obviously, we know without seeing it that they're going to bury Dumbledore — there's no tradition in the Potterverse of eating the honored dead, that I know of — and you could argue the story ends with Dumbledore dying and Harry deciding he can't go back to Hogwarts. But given that the whole sixth book is about the relationship between Harry and Dumbledore in many ways, it feels unsatisfying not to say goodbye to Dumbledore properly. It blunts the emotional impact of the whole story.

This is definitely something I've struggled with in my own work — the locomotive of the story's main plot has deposited my characters at their destination, and is now chugging off into the distance. But the characters are still milling around on the platform, with one last chance to talk to each other, to resolve all of the issues from that long train ride, before they disperse forever.

How do you let these poor beleaguered travelers have their say, without making the reader feel trapped in a railway station?

As far as I can see, there are several uses for a denouement:

1. Explain what the hell happened, that you were too busy detonating things to explain during your climax.

2. Wrap up all the loose ends, including stray plot devices and random plot threads that didn't already get blown up.

3. Give your characters some emotional closure, and one last chance to work through the choices they've made.

4. Hint at how life will go on, after the book is over. (And lay down some landmines for your characters to step on in the sequel, if any.)

5. Provide some resolution to the themes of your story.

I'm basically going to argue that reason #5 is the only absolute requirement for your denouement — and even that can be done in a sentence, if you're deft. Reasons #1-4 may only be necessary if you botched your climax*, and in any case you can let your readers do a lot of heavy lifting, if you provide a few cunning hints about how things are shaking out.

What's The Difference Between Denouement And Picking At A Scab?S

While I was sorting our my thoughts on this topic, I was lucky enough to run into Doug Dorst, author of the amazing Alive In Necropolis, and asked him what he thought made for a good denouement. It turns out he struggled with this same question in his own novel: "I don't think I nailed it. I felt like I was going on and on. It felt like this uneasy series of sacrifices."

By "sacrifices," Dorst means he wanted to give every character a satisfying conclusion to his or her arc, but there just wasn't space "It could have gone on for another hundred pages... I didn't want it to be like the last Lord Of The Rings movie, which had like nine endings."

Dorst came up with one clever solution to his problem: He described one key scene of his denouement only in a police report, which was quick and efficient, plus the form of the police report added a bit of stylized coolness. It wasn't as rich or descriptive as actually narrating the scene, but the reader can always add some of that themselves.

The main thing that occurs to me, after talking to Dorst, is a general maxim: There will always be loose ends. Always. Even if you spent 1,000 pages tying up loose ends after your story begins winding down, all of that frenetic resolution will probably just generate a new batch of loose ends, which you'll need another 1,000 pages to cope with.

Another maxim that occurs to me is: There are a lot of things that are way more interesting to read about when they take place during a crisis. Both because your space wizard will have to speak a lot more concisely when he/she is dodging the enemy's laser-spells at the same time, and because people who think they are about to die tend to make a lot more interesting snap judgments. Think about that bit in the penultimate episode of Buffy season four, where Buffy and her friends process their relationship while climbing down into the evil army monster base: it's a lot more interesting than processing their relationship over iced tea.

Here's what it boils down to, for me. (Feel free to disagree, as always.) The climax is where your plot ends. The denouement is where your story ends.

(We had a lengthy discussion about the difference between plot and story here — suffice to say that I wound up being convinced that "story" means something more emotionally rich, more mythic, more character-centric, than "plot," which is more to do with "we have to find the Mystical Sceptre of Alpha Centauri before the Oort Warlocks do!")

What's The Difference Between Denouement And Picking At A Scab?S

Sometimes your plot and your story end in the same sentence: the space wizard Xxamuel finds the Mystical Sceptre and strikes down the head Oort Warlock, and in that split second, Xxamuel finally understands why his father was so distant throughout his childhood. Xxamuel vanquishes the Oort Warlock, and his longstanding childhood issues, in the very same breath. He stands triumphant, a whole man at last. The end.

But if your plot doesn't end with enough of a clear-cut catharsis to resolve the main themes of your novel, then yes, you need a denouement.

And yes, you may feel as though some of the loose ends of your story are crying out to be addressed. But if that's the case, I'd try and do it as ruthlessly, and quickly, as possible. Remember: readers actually like it when you make them do a lot of the work themselves. And a big part of the pleasure of reaching the end of a book is getting to imagine in your own mind how the characters will go on afterwards — the story keeps unspooling in your head after you stop turning pages, except that the training wheels have come off. So the less you spoonfeed the reader in your final pages, the more you're inviting her/him to start imagining the story after the book ends.

Try borrowing from the cinematic device of the camera's slow pan across the battlefield, in which you glimpse all the characters doing something. So instead of this:

What's The Difference Between Denouement And Picking At A Scab?S

"Xxamuel," said Rachel, "I would have parlance."

"Speak," said Xxamuel, still studying the Mystical Sceptre and admiring its lingering glow.

"We lost much in this battle," Rachel said. "I gave up my Bracelets of Stellar Beauty, and now must walk as a mortal woman through the spacelanes. So I have decided to return to Proxima, there to live in contemplation as my beauty wanes."

"Nay, woman," said Xxamuel. "Stay, and be my wife. With the Mystical Sceptre, all things are possible."

"You cannot keep the Mystical Sceptre," the wise old counselor Zithra interjected. "It must be returned to the Shadowed Halls of Alpha Centauri." He reached for the Sceptre, and Xxamuel considered for a moment, then handed it over with a muttered "Tcha."

"I have a hole in my hand, and yet it still grips," marveled Oxblood, flexing his massive hand to show off the huge circular hole that the magical laser blast had instantly cauterized. "Betimes I shall pilot my shuttle with this hand, and the hole will fit perfectly around the thruster control. Verily, it is a fortunate wound!"

"Now that the Holy Order of Comet Swift has been disbanded," wept Zallah, "I must return to my old vocation as a barmaid in the Jump Station. Those tankards will weigh heavy, even on an antigrav tray."

"Nay, woman," said Xxamuel. "Stay, and be my wife. Rachel will not have me, now that I have lost the Mystical Sceptre."

You can do this:

Xxamuel looked around the shattered remains of his Dome-city throneroom, and saw Rachel already slipping away, tears in her eyes. Xxamuel started to go after Rachel, but the wise Zithra tapped him on the shoulder and took the Mystical Sceptre from his grasp, stowing it safely in his robes. Nearby, Oxblood flexed his wounded hand, marveling that the massive hole did not impair his mighty grip, and Zallah wept into the tatters of her Comet Frost Orbit habit. Over on the far end of the room, Robert the Ogre coughed up a few Oort Warlock bones and slowly, contemplatively, donned the helmet he had so long ago cast aside.

Both examples are pretty wretched, but you get the idea — give us a nice panoramic sweep of your scene, or give us little grace notes that just hint at what your characters are going to do next.

Most of all, try to think of ways those plot loose ends relate to your novel's theme, and make them part of a thematic resolution. I was talking to Annalee about this the other day, and she was saying she thinks of the denouement as the place where the story harkens back to its beginnings — the main plot is resolved, and life settles into a new version of "normal," and in some ways we look back at the status quo that the novel started with.

Say the theme of your novel is "Xxamuel deals with his daddy issues," and maybe in a larger sense, the theme is "family." Then one way to approach all of your loose-end tying is to make sure it all feels like a last approach to the theme. (Without being heavy-handed, of course.) This doesn't mean shoe-horning lingering plot questions into a homily about "family," but rather it's just one way of thinking about which loose ends to prioritize, and which ones you might want to let slide. To the extent that your theme is the sinew of your story (just as plot is the bones) your final moments can feel more weighty if they feel thematic.

But what do you think?

* - This asterisk is dedicated to giggling about the term "climax," which sadly is the best term for what I'm talking about here. They should come up with a better word for this, like "plotgasm." Oh, wait.