Dune is a fantasy story not science fiction (spice is magic not science). That said, I'm a librarian and I see the fantasy books coming out these days. They're like 900 pages long and 20 of them are in a series. I just don't have time for that.
Electronic Frontier Foundation Chairman Brad Templeton's views on the finale quite frankly make me want to defecate. The entire series was imbued with religion. I want my money back... Not from BSG, but from the Electronic Frontier Foundation to which I paid to put a badge on my blog.
I love "Dune." But Dune IS fantasy, not science fiction. How do the pilots fold space? They use a magic dust called "spice." Incidentally, "Star Wars" isn't science fiction either (the Force)... And I love Star Wars.
@kromekoran: I agree. The only thing that might ruin it is if they don't adequately explain how Tigh is a Cylon. His connection to Adama goes back to the First Cylon War so how could this be possible?