Plus, the amount of time and money it'd take to crank out a simulacrum of the real world would be basically crazy prohibitive. Especially compared to the time it takes to crank out a lower-fi stylized product. Besides, doing that would both cost way less AND give your product a unique look to help it stand out!
I think the future lies in a contest of design rather than a race to see who can make the most realistic visuals happen.
You know some tricks? Yeah? You know some cute little Battleship tricks, child? Oh, what's that? You're gonna line all your ships up on one side of the map? I know that trick, son. I know that. I look for that. Oh, you gonna make a little T-shape with the ships so I'll sink one but forget about the other? I KNOW THAT TRICK, TOO. I INVENTED THAT. THAT IS MY DAMN MOVE, SON, YOU TRYIN' TO PULL THAT ON ME? MY OWN MOVE? I WILL DESTROY YOU.
You want to play with me? You better not even look at the board, then, 'cause I can see the reflections in your eyes. I know where your ships are. I know where your battleship is, I know where your carrier is, I know where your dinky little goddamn two-peg patrol boat is. I don't need no sonar to find your sub, kiddo. I know the disposition of your fleet better than you can imagine. I know where your ships are. I know where their captains hide their weed and porno, son. I KNOW WHERE YOUR CREWS SLEEP, BOY-CHILD.
Oh, my fleet? My fleet might as well not even be on the board, far as your fool white-peg-droppin' self is concerned. Listen, you might as well just take all those red pegs over there and give 'em to me. You ain't gonna need 'em, kiddo. You just sit there and call out any damn letters and numbers you want. Splash splash splash, that's all you're gonna hear. IT IS YOUR DESTINY. I HAVE FORSEEN IT.
Listen, admit this to yourself, I know it's hard, but say the words: "I am one seriously doomed old admiral whose fleet is going to sink for nothing and none of my little plastic sailor men are ever going home to their little plastic mommies." Just say it. Get it out of the way. Own up to the fact that you couldn't guess your way out of a wet paper bag.
Then turn your silly pathetic little boats around and sail your sad sack, floatie-wing-wearin', torpedo-wiffin', seasick little old self back down to Candyland, PUNK.
But it was good to have a consistent fictional bad guy back then. At least the USSR gave us that. That, and the worst nuclear disaster the world has ever seen.
Different strokes for different folks.
They were fantastically easy to get at (and you could use the controller packages to store your controllers if you were terrified of DUST MONSTERS), but they changed it all up to clamshells when the big box stores complained that the handy packages were too easy to surreptitiously empty out while they were on the rack.
Still, I'd like to see easy-to-get-open packages become the norm, rather than the tiny fortresses everything comes in now.
Then they should hang up, tear up the script, and decide to make another movie entirely because, seriously, a Quake movie would be terrible.