<![CDATA[Comments from Klebert L. Hall]]> <![CDATA[Comments from Klebert L. Hall]]> <![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Method and Device for Recognizing and Vaporizing]]> Yeah, they are awesome.
But they make fun of IP, which is not popular in the sf-blog-comment-posting world.

-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Fringe Will Jump The Shark Early And Often, Says J.J. Abrams]]> So, Abrams is saying he's a moron.

Didn't we already know that?
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Europeans Play Asteroids — For Real!]]> That first one is pretty and all, but unfortunately completely inaccurate. Although it was a close flyby, the nearest it came was 800km...

-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Energy Ball Turns Your Roof into a Wind Turbine Farm]]> I don't trust that mount design, even a little.

BTW, do these things really qualify as "Mega Turbines"?
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Take Some Time-Traveling Incest On Your Next Long Plane Ride]]> What exactly makes something a "beach novel"?
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Obama Promises National Tech Officer and a Space Advisor to the President]]> I still think it's a bad idea to throw so much politics into the site, but that's not my call.

"What the hell is a "digital smart grid"? Maybe Obama should have consulted with his CTO before using terms like "digital smart grid.""

Yeah, he made it sound silly, but it's actually a worthwhile goal (though not one that it's within the President's powers to achieve).

The current grid is old and not terribly flexible, as it's largely designed for load-sharing between large centralized providers. It isn't very good for things like residential alternative energy producers feeding back in efficiently, and it would be better if it was.
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on What To Expect From Highlander, Dragonball And Star Trek]]> "What To Expect From Highlander, Dragonball And Star Trek"

Here, let me make this shorter for you:

Nothing good.
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on A City Prepared for Disaster Is a City that Looks to the Future]]> New Orleans has been destroyed before (1927, for example), and it will be destroyed again. Will it keep being rebuilt? Probably, as long as the Feds keep paying for it. If it has to come out of Louisiana's pockets, probably not - there's little evidence of State-funded hurricane barrier work in history.

I love New Orleans, and it was my Mom's home town. However, it really needs Netherlands-style ocean defenses, and nobody seems willing to pay for them. The other issue is that every time this happens, the Delta towns get more-or-less erased, and nobody seems to care. I suspect we should probably buy people out, and make most of the delta and bayou into a Federal wetlands wildlife park, but nobody's going to like that.
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Why Not Let Robots Take The Strain?]]> "As a non-American, the fact that the US celebrates Labor Day by taking a vacation has always been of interest and amusement to me. "

Oh, come on - it's somehow sillier than Canada's "Civic Holiday" or the UK's "Bank Holiday" ?

My greatest problem with holidays is that Leap Day isn't one.
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Babylon AD: Yet Another Scifi Flick About the Virgin Mary]]> "She's your basic Catholic allegory lady, totally out of place in a movie about mercenaries, terrorists, refugees, and evil religions."

In what way do those things not go together? You've just described pretty much the entire Middle Ages...

I agree that the whole "women as utility appliance" thing is loathesome, it certainly isn't unusual in fiction or real life. Isn't this movie basically just a shoot 'em up? Women are unfortunately almost always just objects in them - I don't expect much plot or philosphy from that sort of movie.

Joining the chorus on 5th Element - it was a surprisingly faithful adaptation of French "manga", and that stuff pretty much always has ridiculously simplistic, moralistic, nonsense endings. Anime is pretty much the same way, but you don't mind that. I'd say just watch 5th Element in the same way you watch Anime, and enjoy it for the good parts, w/o worrying about the weak philosophy.
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on The Two Missing Essentials For Torchwood Season 3]]> "And now that Dr. Owen Harper has left the building - this time, permanently"

I don't know about that. The folks who wrote that episode really had no inkling of how a nuclear reactor works (nor electricity, for that matter), but even in their silly explanation, I see no reason why Owen wouldn't still be undead, just radioactive now.
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Get Out Of The Way Of Our New Mek Overlords]]> Whatever happened to "mech" ? Four letters just too many?

At least it made some sort of sense...
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on We Will Beam Electricity Directly Into Your Brain -- No Wires Needed]]> Well, our bodies are continually permeated by microwaves (radio, TV, wireless networks, cellphones, etc.) without any amazingly dreadful effects. No reason to think a different method of wireless transmitted power would automatically kill us.

-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Race Has Little to Do with Genetic Makeup, Say Scientists]]> "The Venter paper does not dismiss the usefulness of race as a valid concept, and does not dismiss its usefulness in medicine. "

It doesn't need to, the uselessness of race as a valid concept is implicit on the face of it.

Please provide an example of an instance where "race" is meaningful, and it can't be replaced by "ethnicity".
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on What Are the Unlikeliest Futures for the Human Species?]]> @Grey_Area:
Yeah, it was much more of a "storytelling theory/folklore & mythology" story than a "linguistics" story.

I'm pretty sure that another standard trope that will never happen is transcendence into beings of pure energy... Damn, but I hate that puritan crap.
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Terminator 4 Is Really About The Messiah, McG Says]]> @Belabras:

Nah, it's under the "graven images" clause.
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Texas House Sucked Into Wormhole]]> Very nice.

There was an architect years ago who used to do vaguely similar tromp l'oiel buildings...
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Neal Stephenson Says His New Novel Has Parallels with Bush Era in U.S.]]> ""People who write books, people who work in universities, who work on big projects for a long time, are on a diverging course from the rest of society. Slowly, the two cultures just get further and further apart."

The thing is, this is quite strongly driven by the bigotry of the "intelligentsia". I find that people in the SF community (for example) are much more likely to be prejudiced towards religious folks than vice-versa. Perhaps we should be working on this, instead of happily pushing away and alienating the majority of the population? Telling kids "you're an ignorant, primitive redneck because you go to church with your parents" isn't really a good way to interest them in a rationalist world-view.

@capnrob:
"You just gotta roll with it, sometimes, or else you go all John Brunner."

It's true that it's easy to think this way, but the fact is that the Marching Morons doesn't ever actually happen. Look at how long ago Brunner was writing, for example. Oddly enough, things are actually generally better now than in the '60s and early '70s. Elitism is all well and good (I'm an elitist bastard myself) but you have to take into account that it's a load of bullshit, or your thinking gets all screwed up.

@Moff:
"Getting Bush and his ilk out of office may be akin to treating a symptom, and not actually fighting the disease."

You've hit the nail right on the head, and it'd be a minor symptom at that. However, people would rather have a convenient "ultimate evil" scapegoat than do any actual work or examine whether they might be part of the problem, too.
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on The Return of "Wizard of Gore" -- Drugged-Out Scifi the Way It Was Meant to Be]]> Huh.
I didn't see that coming.
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on A Mutant Roll Call For Tokyo Gore Police [NSFW]]]> Yep, that's Japanese, all right.
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Race Has Little to Do with Genetic Makeup, Say Scientists]]> As I've said here and elsewhere before, there is no such thing as race.

It is a political concept, not a scientific one.

The same can be said for racism, as generally used - the proper term is bigotry.
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Grow an Exoskeleton with Bone-Generating Hydrogel]]> @Chetverikov:

If it makes you feel any better, I beat you to it by about an hour...
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Scifi's Greatest Space Builders — And How We'll Copy Them]]> @richardmayhew:
"How exactly would you manage to inflate the lungs with water without dying?"

There's a flourocarbon (IIRC) fluid that works as an oxygen carrier that's used for very deep-sea diving. The divers aspirate their lungs full of it so that the lungs don't collapse at depth. Seems creepy as hell, but it actually works.
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Game Your Way into the Star Wars Expanded Universe with a New Guide]]> @twophrasebark:
Oddly enough, it's usually a direct variation for the players of RPGs...
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on The Russian Cold War Rocket That Still Does Heavy Lifting]]> What the heck is all over the top third of it? I could swear they don't always look like that...

-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Grow an Exoskeleton with Bone-Generating Hydrogel]]> Generally, horns and such are made out of hair or fingernails. The Narwhal is an exception, because that's a tooth.
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Scifi's Greatest Space Builders — And How We'll Copy Them]]> "Other space megastructures, such as ringworlds, discworlds, Dyson Spheres and artificial planets, would be impossible, or near-impossible, to build inside an existing gravity well."

Um, they're in a star's gravity well...
Maybe "would require microgravity for construction" ?
Or, maybe not, since they have their own gravity.
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Game Your Way into the Star Wars Expanded Universe with a New Guide]]> Hmm... [looks at cover art]
Which Jedi power gives you giant boobs?
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Grow an Exoskeleton with Bone-Generating Hydrogel]]> This has plenty of excellent potential uses, but bulletproof exoskeletons are not one of them.

Bone has really poor resistance to penetration per weight.
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on How Far Inside Your Brain Does That iPod Get?]]> Okay, first the National Enquirer starts doing real journalism, then USA Today (pretty bad, but not previously tabloid-quality) runs this crap. WTF?
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Coming Soon from China: Dystopic Futures, the Next Steve Jobs, and a World Full of Drumming Androids]]> @ManchuCandidate:
@Coxswain:

Right, but desalinization *is* easy, it just costs money (though you can do it in a low-yield manner for free).

Your point about cheap energy is right on target, but you miss how that overwhelms the water issue. If we don't have cheap energy, we can't support the world population anyway. Dead people don't need water.

As for the "brackishness" issue; what, now you're worrying about luxuries like flavor? That doesn't really fit into a water-scarceness scenario.
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on The Imperial Forces Overrun Home Of America's Liberal Elite]]> I'm afraid I prefer San Francisco without the Star Wars lameness.

I wouldn't be so proud of LucasArts HQ, either...

-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Coming Soon from China: Dystopic Futures, the Next Steve Jobs, and a World Full of Drumming Androids]]> @sega8800:
"1. Fresh Water is going to be a global problem."

Not really, making fresh water is absurdly trivial.

"3. China doesn't hesitate to use genetic engineered food. This can't be done in United States because people reject it. "

You're confusing us with Europe.
Most processed food in the US contains some GM products.
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Coming Soon from China: Dystopic Futures, the Next Steve Jobs, and a World Full of Drumming Androids]]> "The current regime could be toppled, he says, if China were to be hit with a series of natural disasters, terrorist attacks, and bad political decisions (like if they invaded Iraq and accrued a huge budget deficit... hint hint)"

If you're going to insist upon making political jibes, could you please, please, go read some history so that the jibes make sense? The US has been in enormously worse situations vis-a-vis war and economy in the past, and the current situation is vanishingly unlikely to result in a change of our form of government.

Criticism is more effective when it is accurate and germane.
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Riff Raff Curses MTV's Rocky Horror Remake]]> @reddingofish:

Sure, but your point (which I agree with) seems to be that the original was crap.

So, what's to lose? I suggest not watching it.
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on A Bright Vision Of An Eco-Friendly Utopia]]> Hey, hippie art in San Francisco - I'm shocked.
Shocked, I tells ya.
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Hey New Lara Croft, Are Those Guns For Real?]]> @ThatGuyOverThere:

Amongst many other things, yes.
-Kle.

]]>
<![CDATA[Klebert L. Hall commented on Trent Reznor Is HBO's Great Scifi Hope?]]> @:

Okay, that's at least less silly. "in the middle of a nuclear war" tends to sound like the missiles have been launched, but haven't hit yet.
-Kle.

]]>