Enter your username and password.
San Francisco, 6:34 AM
Wed Nov 11
30 posts in the last 24 hours

Tip your editors: tips@io9.com
Editor-in-Chief:
Annalee Newitz | Email
News Editor:
Charlie Jane Anders | Email
Associate Editor:
Meredith Woerner | Email
Assistant Editor:
Lauren Davis | Email
Weekend Editor:
Graeme McMillan | Email
Contributors:
Joshua Glenn
Stephen Goldmeier | Email
Ed Grabianowski | Email
Austin Grossman
Paul Hogan | Email
Lauren Davis | Email
Chris Hsiang | Email
Lynn Peril | Email
Ann VanderMeer
Alasdair Wilkins | Email
Graphic Designer:
Stephanie Fox | Email
Interns:
Tim Barribeau | Email
Julia Carusillo | Email
Alex Eichler | Email
Cyriaque Lamar | Email
Caitlin Petrakovitz | Email
Mary Ratliff | Email
Josh Snyder | Email
Please enter your email address to have your password reset.
Registering will give you a user profile and the ability to add other users as friends. To become a commenter, however, you need to audition.
Want to know more? Consult the Comment FAQ and legal terms.
You don't need to login to comment. Just enter your email address below.
See how your address will be displayed in the Comment FAQ.
04/03/09
04/03/09
Or, maybe, y'know... just a final laugh and bit of fun and reference -- gene hunt on Mars, and Gene Hunt on Mars.
04/03/09
Sam going over to the Dark side, in retrospect, is there, but it's another thing that really should have been more visible - I was thrilled, in the pilot, to see him contemplate killing the kid - not that he was going to kill a child, but because the creators seemed to really drop the storyline after that point. His father, in the finale, said that Sam was a monster, or something like that, but we never really see that in the show. Another problem - show, don't tell.
Keitel really wasn't that much of a weak link in the show - I think he did the character pretty well. I was less happy with Annie Norris throughout the entire show - she paled in comparison to Annie Cartwright, and her promotion at the end of the show was a weak footnote with nothing behind it.
Finally that stupid space ship. The writers seemed to have absolutely no clue about interstellar travel. First, you don't take the whole ship down to the surface - this is why we have a lander - it worked very well with Apollo, and any martian mission will likely take along the same components. There was no time lag between transmissions (I know this is nitpicky, but it's bothering me). Plus, they were walking around as if there was gravity. A lot of these things could have been done easily.
04/03/09
04/03/09
First, no one was every really in danger, no one was ever really saved. Sam didn't correct history, like in the British series. Sam didn't sacrifice his future to save his friends in the past.
Only going 13 episodes I think this ending works, but if had gone on a few years I would have felt very cheated if everything turned out to be a dream. But that aside:
Some of the characters had scenes that Sam didn't see. Remember that episode where Annie becomes partners with Ray for a day? Sam has no idea what her day is like, why are we seeing it if its only in his brain?
Also, Annie saves Sam a couple of times, including in the finale. She is back at the police station piecing together clues, etc. Again Sam isn't there to experience it. Are we to believe Annie is another part of Sam's brain coming to rescue him?
A much better way to end it would be to have the 2008 Sam wake up on the spaceship and have him do a stint in the future. He would be the socially backward misfit then. We could not only see how far we've come as a society, but how far we still have to go.
04/03/09
04/03/09
04/03/09
And UK Sam's last second wasn't an eternity -- he "died in the past" after a few years.
US Sam's fantasy at least was based on actual people who behaved much the same.
And the scenes that weren't from his POV were partly computer generated to fill in the gaps; that's how he/we knew what Annie did by herself, since his feelings about Annie were obviously a big part of it. Or else his subconscious came up with that, too, since he really likes her and wanted to dream about her.
The Brit version got caught up in not wanting to be an SF show after they'd used the tropes and mechanisms. They tried to have it both ways. The American version proudly owned its SF-ness.
04/03/09
why did they have to bring in astonauts and mars? is it really so that americans don't get metaphors? does a show called "life on mars" necessarily have to be about mars at some point - even if it's in an ending forcefully stapled to the show?
04/03/09
04/03/09
04/03/09
04/03/09
04/03/09
It was nice to hear "Life is a Rock" again; I've always liked that song, though I prefer the Tracey Ullman version. It fit in very well with the episode (and entire series).
04/03/09
04/03/09
04/02/09
04/02/09
04/02/09
I'll miss you most of all, No-Nuts.
(That's a mean name, and I'll stop using it now.)
04/02/09
But the cancellation cheated us out of that, not the ending. Season 2 would have had cop Sam dating No More No Nuts, for sure.
04/02/09
Something!
(Not that I'm all into romance and stuff. Anyway.)
04/02/09
Didn't you see the looks they were giving each other in the capsule? They are totally gonna be the first people to Do It on Mars.
One small step indeed.
04/02/09
My review is here: [jeditrilobite.wordpress.com]
04/02/09
I'm disappointed by the ending, but not as much as I would have been had I invested 5-6 years in the show. They were starting to develop the characters so well - especially his relationship with Annie and then poof, it never was. It's the Bobby Ewing Ending.
I'd rather they left it at the kiss, or him hanging up the phone, or even him hugging Hunt. Any of those would have been better. Then again, we'd all be complaining that they ripped off The Sopranos. :)
04/02/09
04/02/09
04/02/09
Here's my take: I think the reason Sam and Alex both end up with Gene Hunt in various time periods is that Hunt is in a coma as well (in the present). Not sure why people keep ending up experiencing Hunt's life with him, but that's my theory.
It's Gene whose coma life people are gravitating towards. Maybe he's in a nearby hospital room. I dunno.
04/02/09
04/03/09
Well, my TV explanation is that Gene's real first name was Meredith. Or Evelyn.
04/03/09
04/03/09
04/03/09
04/03/09
You do realize this is a show where people travel back in time while being a coma?
04/03/09
04/03/09
:p
What do I get if I'm right?
04/02/09
Also also, Sam is and always has been the main character/focus of the US version as opposed to Gene being ditto in the UK one.
04/02/09
I know some people are whining about the "all a dream" part, but face it -- so was the original!
This one actually made more sense -- the details were so correct b/c the computer was keeping track of trivia, and not Sam's brain. Plus all the little weirdnesses are wrapped up neatly.
I thought they were gonna go with returning to 2008 to find Annie was Sam's boss or something -- which they kinda faked out with the 2010 ending.
This is better than if they'd done a cliffhanger at Sam deciding to stay and never gotten to do anything with it.
The details of the 2035 sequence are very nice when you watch them the second time through and can pay attention.
I give them the cheat of talking to Earth real-time b/c you can't bore the audience waiting for minutes round-trip as they chat with home.
Life On Mars, indeed.
04/02/09
04/02/09
04/02/09
Also, the British ending made me retroactively think less of/dislike Sam. This one makes me still like him.
04/02/09
They wanted 7 years of this. A 4 minute wrap up of "it was all a virtual reality!" would've been fucking insane.
But one concise season? I dunno, for some reason that seems more...okay. Still though, I can't help but think anything the show was trying to say rings completely hollow now that it turns out none of it had any consequence at all. Was it really their plan all along to have the ending be something that completely renders everythin that came before it totally inconsequential? Like, this was all about Sam reconciling with his dad, who was really his boss anyways? I mean, we don't even know why Sam was so fucking mad at Gene that he tripped through time trying to fix his relationship, yet still could go on a space mission with him to Mars anyways no problem.
Like, seriously, I feel like there's gotta be a whole 'nother show explaining why the fuck I should care about the characters at the end of this show!
When he wakes up and his whole experience almost totally had zero fucking effect on him and he instantly remembered, "oh yea, I'm on a space flight to mars, duh! Silly me." how am I supposed to care?!
What would've been better is that, the final final scene is everything was a fakeout and it's him still in a coma and it turns out he's still trapped in his mind. That way, you get your explanation for everything, consequences are in tact in some way, but he's forever doomed to loop through time. Something less hopeful and doesn't wrap it all up in a cheesy bow.
Also, why the hell would there be a father/son mission to Mars where the father is in his 60s? I would think there would be way better candidates for this incredibly important mission. Who woulda thunk? HARVEY KEITEL IN SPACE. Lol. I give the ending points for pure balls, but seriously, what the fuck guys.
04/03/09
04/03/09
04/02/09
Although I'm disappointed to see that they never did learn to use the 70s music effectively. What's with all the "look at those cavemen go!" lyric quotes, and then never actually playing "Life on Mars"??
It looks like they would've actually explored the Hyde thing more if the show had lasted, which would have been nice - that was underused in the British.
04/02/09
04/02/09
Another music thought: I was glad they avoided the Over The Rainbow temptation. Yes, the British used that wonderful ukulele recording and the whole sequence was beautiful, but really, rather ham-fisted. The American dispensed with the Wizard of Oz stuff with a quickie Scarecrow reference. So A+ there.
04/02/09
The Brit version using "Over the Rainbow" was kind of cliche, actually; after ER used the Hawaiian version in that big ep where the guy died, it's sort of ruined for anything else TV-drama-ending-wise.
04/02/09
Don't remember it from ER. Stopped watching ER for like ten years in there. Half-watching the finale at the moment, though. It's no House. Keep thinking about LoM instead. Which I guess is why I'm commenting the hell out of this recap while watching ER. Whatevs.
04/02/09
I see we will have to agree to disagree. They did play "Life on Mars" at the beginning of the show, so the Bowie references/lyrics at the end were quite sufficient whereas playing it again would be both redundant and too "GET IT? GET IT, HUH? SEE, AREN'T WE CLEVER?"
(is there more Clooney in the finale, or was his bit a couple weeks ago it? that's all I really care about)
04/02/09
No Clooney. :( Pretty uneventful. Though they showed the exterior of the hospital for the first time at the very end, that was cool.
04/02/09
but I digress... um, um, that visit was before Clooney was Batman! He was Batman once. Batman is an io9 topic!
04/02/09
JUST LIKE EXTERIORS OF SPACESHIPS! Relevance ftw!
04/02/09