io9 
Enter your username and password.
San Francisco, 9:45 PM
Fri Nov 27
17 posts in the last 24 hours
Tip your editors: tips@io9.com
Editor-in-Chief:
Annalee Newitz | Email
News Editor:
Charlie Jane Anders | Email
Associate Editor:
Meredith Woerner | Email
Assistant Editor:
Lauren Davis | Email
Weekend Editor:
Graeme McMillan | Email
Contributors:
Joshua Glenn
Stephen Goldmeier | Email
Ed Grabianowski | Email
Austin Grossman
Paul Hogan | Email
Lauren Davis | Email
Chris Hsiang | Email
Lynn Peril | Email
Ann VanderMeer
Alasdair Wilkins | Email
Graphic Designer:
Stephanie Fox | Email
Interns:
Tim Barribeau | Email
Julia Carusillo | Email
Alex Eichler | Email
Cyriaque Lamar | Email
Caitlin Petrakovitz | Email
Mary Ratliff | Email
Josh Snyder | Email
Original material is licensed under a Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing with attribution.
11/26/09
11/26/09
The era of colonialism really wasn't that long ago, and really never ended in many ways. Arguably, economic globalization is mainly a continuation of the process. And whether or not you believe the invasion of Iraq and Afghanistan were justified or even heroic attempts to create freedom... for some reason we still can't resist helping ourselves to their oil.
So the point is: the same mindset that created colonialism is still alive and well in Western culture, and plenty of non-Western cultures, too.
The only humans I can safely imagine coexisting with aliens are people from many of the same cultures that were almost entirely wiped out by colonialism.
Many of these cultures were entirely uninterested in conquering anybody and would have been humanity's best ambassadors, had they not been conquered by less civilized societies.
11/26/09
This is not to say that we are in any way enlightened but to imagine that an encounter with aliens today would automatically turn into an Aztec-style slaughter is equally unlikely.
In the current social climate there would simply be debate and debate and debate until a course of action could be agreed upon that required very little action and almost no accountability.
We are no longer savages...we are bureaucrats. At least the savages stood for something - even if it was an irrational genocidal hatred.
07:36 AM
Like it or not, we "civilized" folk tend to carry an attitude of domination--a holdover from our feudal agrarian days that's built into our political, economic, and religious institutions.
That, and it's often the people who were historically classed as "savages" who tended to be far more civilized. Obviously not in all cases, but in many cases the culture in question was wholly uninterested in power.
02:17 PM
My point is that the large scale imperialists have moved from slaughter to hand-wringing. You could simply blame or credit the media for this but now, as you pointed out, it is done with deals and treaties.
The slaughters today tend to occur within national borders and to peoples who are arguably part of the cultures who slaughters them.
As to the Iraqi oil contracts. Yep, friends got the construction contracts. But Iraq gets all the oil. That is in fact the center of a minor controversy in the US.
And no, it seems that the current administration is no different. Worse possibly.
11/26/09
I wouldn't argue for a story that's all about peaceful coexistence. I realize that that's boring. What I'd be interesting in seeing is a story where the immigrants come in peace, and then see how good intentions can go horribly awry. I still think there's dramatic heft there.
11/26/09
I mean, seriously. Have you tried *reading* le Guin's _Always Coming Home_?
11/26/09
And, sadly, I doubt any of us will live to see it. Hopefully, someone else will.
11/26/09
11/26/09
[www.imdb.com]
Or "Will the Real Martian Please Stand Up?"
[www.veoh.com]
Or "Third from the Sun"
[www.cbs.com]
11/26/09
11/26/09
cj cherryh's Foreigner series is probably a good example of the pilgrim idea...
11/26/09
Because art imitates life....
Besides, who REALLY wants to watch us make peace with a bunch of noble space savages when we can either bilk them out of their land with some Neptunian beads, or just kill 'em for sport. ;)
11/26/09
11/26/09
11/26/09
"Hi, we're from a planet far away. We call it earth. Mind if we set up a colony here on your planet and look around at all it's wonders?"
"No, of course not. make yourselves at home. How about if some of us do the same on this 'earth' of yours?"
"Hey, no problem. Go crazy. Knock yourselves out. Maybe we can trade, get rich and interbreed?"
"Sure, sounds great. Glad we met."
The End.
I don't know about you, but I'm fascina.....zzzzzzzz.
11/26/09
I'd much rather just watch Kevin Costner try to make peace with them until the rest of the whitemen come to follow divine providence and kill whatever isn't white and doesn't have a vagina....
11/26/09
Didn't CONTACT deal with the early steps towards peaceful co-existence? That might be the closest we've come. What makes it hard is the scope of such a production, at least in terms of film. A movie where we go to an alien world only to sit around and act chummy wouldn't exactly put asses in theater seats, and as Cameron has illustrated with his mega-production, you need to hedge your bets with surefire dramatic tension (ie. killing of the indigenous lifeforms).
This is something easier to pull off in prose where not as much money is riding on the project.
11/26/09
Humanity is, in general, violent. And for stupid reasons, I might add. That's why in real life E.T's haven't visited us. We've frakked up not only members of our own race, but other species whenever we get the chance, whether accidentally or on purpose, whether on the sea or in the sky. Terran real estate didn't use to suck until we started bombing the crap out of everything and pumping toxic waste into the air. And all those elk carcasses couldn't be a good sign--Sarah Palin alone should be one big blinking "AVOID EARTH" sign to whatever extraterrestrials may be out there.
Also, technological advancement only comes when there's some hapless species you can test it on. And THAT is why alien/human conflict in the movies is so much fun. :)
Peace sucks and so do black holes. :P
11/26/09
Quit buying into the equally dumb myth of the "noble, wise, living-in-harmony-with-the-environment Native Americans".
11/26/09
Disagree.
11/26/09
Perhaps, but it's quite likely you only believe that because you live in a warlike culture in the first place.
11/26/09
As it is, they have to somehow reconcile ancient values with modern ones, and with modern tools and modern pressures. Of course people are going to act stupidly in that case.
I'm not saying they're magical in any way, but with an intact culture, they'd more than likely behave much more intelligently.
11/26/09
11/26/09
06:03 AM
"Perhaps, but it's quite likely you only believe that because you live in a warlike culture in the first place."
Would I rather live in a peaceful society? Of course. Absolutely.
Do I want to read about it/watch a movie about it? Not really. To paraphrase Eddie Izzard, it's just hard to eat popcorn to that kind of story.
(And while Toronto is rather grumpy at times, I hesitate to describe it as "war-like". Unless you mean human culture in general, in which case, who doesn't?)
07:25 AM
(but, still, Yay Toronto! I love and greatly miss that city!)
06:19 PM
Sarah Palin shooting things from the sky, rogue Native caribou poachers, I don't think the aliens will tell the difference. Historically & typically Native Americans have been the more environmentally conscientious community, but hey, when the Romans have taken over your space and kicked you to the backstreet, do as the Romans do, I guess. It's just too bad that nobody ever thinks to ask the "trophy game" whether they want to rot into the ground or be dried, stuffed and hung on some hick's wall.
But all I'm saying is somebody better pay for Three Mile Island since my generation's going to be paying for it for the next century. Savvy? :)
11/26/09
Anyone know a date for that episode. I need to set a reminder to download it.
11/26/09
11/26/09
And also, Barrowman's accent is just bizzare isn't it? Its a weird scottish/american mix, then he goes right back into american, and sounds normal.
11/26/09
Which I guess doesn't matter for Capt. Jack since he's from the future.
11/26/09
Adam Baldwin and Joshua Gomez would make frequent guest appearances.
11/25/09