avatarcasting

posts about #avatarcasting more →
Shyamalan's Avatar Cast Gets Colorful, Finally

Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

Dsmvwl Admin Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×

Quilt
02/03/09

In reply to Shyamalan's Avatar Cast Gets Colorful, Finally
Does it really matter who'd playing the parts? It's an M. Night Shyamalan movie. That's a guarantee right there that I won't watch it.
Reply

Quilt was starred Quilt was unstarred

Demonbird
02/03/09

In reply to Shyamalan's Avatar Cast Gets Colorful, Finally
So we dropped Whitey mcCasper and picked up Huge-Ears McTwigboy, and people think that's any better?
Reply

Demonbird was starred Demonbird was unstarred

rufustfyrfly
02/03/09

In reply to Shyamalan's Avatar Cast Gets Colorful, Finally
Making all the characters white is just insulting to our intelligence. Most of the show takes place in a medieval east-Asia-themed world, not in medieval western Europe. It would be bad enough if it took place in a modern, multiracial society, with non-white characters, and they switched that up. But that's not even it! It takes place in Asia! Hey let's remake Yojimbo, keep the samurai, feudal Japan theme, but cast a bunch of white guys! WTF!

Maybe you could make a case for the swamp guys being white, but I doubt they are making the cut.

I guess I just don't get the impetus to remake this. Well, okay, I do get it--more money! But why do people keep "remaking" modern, already existing cartoons and movies? They aren't adapting a book here, it already exists on screen. Why do we need "The Ring" when we have "Ringu"? Do they just think that we whiteys are delicate flowers who can't take seeing non-white actors?

If you're not re-imagining it for a reasonable artistic purpose (think BSG) then don't make it!
Reply

rufustfyrfly was starred rufustfyrfly was unstarred

CodenameV
02/03/09

@rufustfyrfly: Recast Yojimbo with white actors? Shirley, you mean "A Fistful of Dollars"?
Reply

CodenameV was starred CodenameV was unstarred

crashedpc - Haifisch
02/03/09

@CodenameV: Oh, don't forget "The Magnificent Seven" aka "Seven Samurai with pistols and muthafuckin Yul Brynner"
Reply

Evil Tortie's Mom: R.O.A.C.H.
02/03/09

@CodenameV: No, I think he meant "recast 'Red Harvest' with Japanese actors."

(srsly, Dashiell Hammett, anyone?)
Reply

Alexis
02/03/09

In reply to Shyamalan's Avatar Cast Gets Colorful, Finally
As a fan of the show, I genuinely don't know how to feel about this. On the one hand, casting this kid (as great an actor as he might be) seems just as "off" as before. On the other hand, my other option was Jesse no talent, generic personality McCartney.

So I'll go with Dev. I just hope that this kid's acting makes me forget how pissed I am that they're not even trying to stay close to the original source material.
Reply

Alexis was starred Alexis was unstarred

evilmike
02/03/09

In reply to Shyamalan's Avatar Cast Gets Colorful, Finally
One thing that I've been curious about since the original story broke -- does anyone actually know what Noah Ringer looks like?
Reply

evilmike was starred evilmike was unstarred

Alexis
02/03/09

@evilmike:

As far as I can tell, there's no pic of him floating around the internets yet.
Reply

Alexis was starred Alexis was unstarred

reddingofish
02/03/09

In reply to Shyamalan's Avatar Cast Gets Colorful, Finally
My kid watches that show and I am pretty sure that the main character is not an American.
Reply

reddingofish was starred reddingofish was unstarred

rufustfyrfly
02/03/09

@reddingofish: The voice actors usually had American-sounding accents, but there was no "America" in the word of Avatar, just element-themed kingdoms. Clearly, the show was anti-American.
Reply

rufustfyrfly was starred rufustfyrfly was unstarred

Quilt
02/03/09

@rufustfyrfly: Well, the characters WERE a part of a huge rebellion against an "evil" empire. The show obviously supports terrorism.
Reply

Quilt was starred Quilt was unstarred

浴武士!!!! I'd like to start a manga like that
02/03/09

In reply to Shyamalan's Avatar Cast Gets Colorful, Finally
what was the reason why they didnt wnat to cast asians for the main roles?

I seriously dont get movie producers.....at least when theres some dude connected in a story, my country(Japan) tries the best they can to get a white dude in the movie....no matter how bad the actor is...
Reply

crashedpc - Haifisch
02/03/09

@スッパー！monkey!: That reminds me, have you seen Sukiyaki Western Django? Talk about an insane mashup of cultures.
Reply

浴武士!!!! I'd like to start a manga like that
02/03/09

@crashedpc: o i made a typo when theres some foreign dude....

and yes I have and its not that bad, actor from Casshern is in it and Tarantino.....umm yea dont get me started on his performance lol....lets say not my standards
Reply

crashedpc - Haifisch
02/03/09

@スッパー！monkey!: Tarantino made me want to punch the screen. The rest of it was surprisingly cool... the director's commentary noted that the main actor provided his own wardrobe cuz he was a Spaghetti Western fanatic.
Reply

Log1c
02/03/09

In reply to Shyamalan's Avatar Cast Gets Colorful, Finally
I would have been fine with Zuko being a white kid, its more Sokka and the rest that were stupid decisions.
Reply

Log1c was starred Log1c was unstarred

crashedpc - Haifisch
02/03/09

@Log1c: To beat the shit out of a dead horse, maybe the skin color's the TWIST! At the end of the movie, they'll peel off their masks, Mission Impossible style, and my parents will be on the screen. *shrieks* I just scared myself!
Reply

cletar
02/03/09

In reply to Shyamalan's Avatar Cast Gets Colorful, Finally
M. Night Shyamalan's still making movies? Huh. Will Bruce Willis reprise his role as the surprisingly dead guy?
Reply

cletar was starred cletar was unstarred

crashedpc - Haifisch
02/03/09

@cletar: He still has SOME goodwill from his, uh, successes. How could he possibly screw this move up?
Reply

twDarkflame
02/03/09

In reply to Shyamalan's Avatar Cast Gets Colorful, Finally
Personally, I'm quite relived that wouldn't change just because fans on the internet moaned about it.

A film that changes course every time there's a "fan outcry" would be an utter mess.
Reply

twDarkflame was starred twDarkflame was unstarred

crashedpc - Haifisch
02/03/09

@twDarkflame: Yeah, but if, say, Predator was remade in, say, Budapest, and, say, the commandos are now graveyard shift landfill inspectors, and, say, the Predator was actually a rabid monkey, perhaps there would be justification in the outcry.

please gods don't be mad at me i'm just being snarky today
Reply

Alexis
02/03/09

@twDarkflame:

I think this a weirdly broad statement to make. I get what you're saying, but directors should listen to fans. They don't need to change every little thing to appease everyone, but there should be a certain amount of respect for fan loyalty. This isn't like when people bitched about Sue Storm not being blonde(when it was easily fixable), this is a little more poignant than that. It was the whitewashing of one of the few popular kids shows that features characters of Asian descent. Fans have every right to bitch about the major decisions in their favorite franchises.
Reply

Alexis was starred Alexis was unstarred

B
02/03/09

In reply to Shyamalan's Avatar Cast Gets Colorful, Finally
What a Twist!
Reply

B was starred B was unstarred

DeepFriar
02/03/09

In reply to Shyamalan's Avatar Cast Gets Colorful, Finally
That's something, surely...?

You'd think so, but blog commenters aren't exactly known for being reasonable or forgiving in nature.

Me especially
Reply

DeepFriar was starred DeepFriar was unstarred

crashedpc - Haifisch
02/03/09

@DeepFriar: Turn on the Snarkotron!
Reply

crashedpc - Haifisch
02/03/09

In reply to Shyamalan's Avatar Cast Gets Colorful, Finally
This truly great news in youth culture will surely counterbalance Miley Cyrus' delightful photoshoot with her "Asian" friends. *walks away grumbling* First damn thing I read on the Interwebs today... need to Irish up my coffee now.
Reply

crashedpc - Haifisch
02/03/09

@crashedpc: But anyway, I think Shyamalan didn't want to admit that his original casting choice was pissing off tons of Asian Americans, so he went ahead and used that boot camp excuse. I'm going to go shove a boot up someone's ass now.
Reply

LittleDragon
02/03/09

@crashedpc: Asian Americas? He casting choice pissed off every body, regardless of ethnicity.
Reply

LittleDragon was starred LittleDragon was unstarred

crashedpc - Haifisch
02/03/09

@LittleDragon: Yeah, true enough. But I gotta show solidarity with my people, you know?
Reply

Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion

#avatarcasting

io9

SUBSCRIBE TO io9

Shyamalan's Avatar Cast Gets Colorful, Finally

Login

Reset Password

Register

Submit Your Comment