Simple... everyone e-mail Stanik, his agent, and his publisher with the single body text "We feel that Robert Stanik needs to stop posting false reviews."
No mail bombs, no repeaters, just a simple, polite message, once a day, for one full year.
I should point out for completeness' sake that I'm not entirely convinced Stanek has posted any 1-star ratings of my books on Amazon. There are a couple of them floating around, but not enough for me to believe that there's a pattern to it. As shocking as it is for me to contemplate, I think it's remotely possible that some random readers out there just didn't like my books. I know, I know! Implausible in the extreme, but it could happen. ;-)
Mr. Rothfuss, however, is another story. Seems like a pretty obvious review-bombing campaign to me.
hey, i just wanted to say i got a kick out of seeing that bit about Giles Goat-Boy. i honestly don't know anyone else who read that book, and i love it too. i admit i haven't read any of your books, but i am definitely interested in checking them out now.
@Oz Mendoza: Giles Goat Boy is one of my fave novels of all time. Found it on Bruce Sterling's recommended reading list of slipstream novels, about 10 years ago, I think.
I always assumed WSJ readers didn't read fiction, let alone have imaginations. Yes, I'm a capitalist-hater, but I want to read these books anyway.
And hey, I bought the Shadowrun books without playing! Next stop: acclaimed sci-fi author. But seriously, I did intend to play but it wasn't "cool" enough for my nerdy friends. There is _nothing_ cooler than a troll with a mono-molecule-bladed axe and a USB in his skull. Nothing!
and the Dayworld method: Invent a 100% reliable method of suspended animation, then split the population into seven groups. Everybody spends one day out of the week going about their regular business and the other six in suspended animation or "stoned". Each day a different person lives in your apartment, goes to your office, and does your job.
On the plus side, you're only using 1/7th of the planet's natural resources and you don't really notice the difference, other than the seasons passing 7x as quickly, but on the other hand, you've got at least 6 other roommates who leave the cap off the toothpaste and the toilet seat up, and there's absolutely no way you can confront them about their 1/7th of the back rent.
The Charlie Jade method: Step 1: Punch an atificial wormhole into a parallel universe with an idyllic version of The Earth, where everybody recycles and the planet's natural resources remain largely unspoiled. Step 2: Exploit the hell out of those ungrateful hippies! Step 3: Profit!
If we're talking Doctor who episodes, there's also the classic Claws of Axos method:
In this 3rd Doctor episode, the beautiful golden-skinned Axons land on Earth in desparate need of fuel. In exchange for a jumpstart from one of our nuclear reactors, they are prepared to offer us the miracle of Axonite-- a "thinking" molecule capable of replicating any substance (or at the very least, supersizing frogs). In one fell swoop, world hunger can be completely eliminated! All they ask is that the Axonite is distributed equally among the world's powers, so that everyone gets their fair share of this glorious bounty from the stars.
If it all sounds a bit too good to be true, it is. The Axons, Axonite, and their earwax-colored spaceship all turn out to be part of the same parasitic organism, and once activated, will suck the Earth dry of all forms of energy, including human life itself.
The Doctor sends the intergalactic carpetbaggers packing with the help of a handy dandy time-loop but not before reminding us that no matter where you travel in this great and mysterious universe, there ain't no such thing as a free lunch.
06/23/09
No mail bombs, no repeaters, just a simple, polite message, once a day, for one full year.
That should get the point across nicely.
06/23/09
If he does have a real publisher, this is the perfect idea.
06/23/09
Mr. Rothfuss, however, is another story. Seems like a pretty obvious review-bombing campaign to me.
06/23/09
06/23/09
06/23/09
06/23/09
06/23/09
06/23/09
06/23/09
(srsly, that's a good idea)
06/23/09
06/23/09
Jordan? Hahahaha... sorry, all respects to his estate, but I'm not going to finish the WoT series.
Stanek? Not anymore, no.
Sock puppets?
06/23/09
Knock that off! I fear for my house everytime you use that.
06/23/09
02/26/09
02/27/09
02/26/09
And hey, I bought the Shadowrun books without playing! Next stop: acclaimed sci-fi author. But seriously, I did intend to play but it wasn't "cool" enough for my nerdy friends. There is _nothing_ cooler than a troll with a mono-molecule-bladed axe and a USB in his skull. Nothing!
02/26/09
02/26/09
02/26/09
02/26/09
02/27/09
11/26/08
11/26/08
Invent a 100% reliable method of suspended animation, then split the population into seven groups. Everybody spends one day out of the week going about their regular business and the other six in suspended animation or "stoned". Each day a different person lives in your apartment, goes to your office, and does your job.
On the plus side, you're only using 1/7th of the planet's natural resources and you don't really notice the difference, other than the seasons passing 7x as quickly, but on the other hand, you've got at least 6 other roommates who leave the cap off the toothpaste and the toilet seat up, and there's absolutely no way you can confront them about their 1/7th of the back rent.
11/26/08
The Charlie Jade method: Step 1: Punch an atificial wormhole into a parallel universe with an idyllic version of The Earth, where everybody recycles and the planet's natural resources remain largely unspoiled. Step 2: Exploit the hell out of those ungrateful hippies! Step 3: Profit!
11/26/08
In this 3rd Doctor episode, the beautiful golden-skinned Axons land on Earth in desparate need of fuel. In exchange for a jumpstart from one of our nuclear reactors, they are prepared to offer us the miracle of Axonite-- a "thinking" molecule capable of replicating any substance (or at the very least, supersizing frogs). In one fell swoop, world hunger can be completely eliminated! All they ask is that the Axonite is distributed equally among the world's powers, so that everyone gets their fair share of this glorious bounty from the stars.
If it all sounds a bit too good to be true, it is. The Axons, Axonite, and their earwax-colored spaceship all turn out to be part of the same parasitic organism, and once activated, will suck the Earth dry of all forms of energy, including human life itself.
The Doctor sends the intergalactic carpetbaggers packing with the help of a handy dandy time-loop but not before reminding us that no matter where you travel in this great and mysterious universe, there ain't no such thing as a free lunch.
11/26/08