So, essentially Will Smith said, "Write me another movie to put one of my precious kids in. Oh, yeah, and she's been bugging me about going to England, so work that in there somewhere."
@noamjamski: Why does Hollywood not get that it is the ending that makes the book a classic?
"Here is a book with some cultural staying power, so to make it a success we should remove everything special about it. Another brilliant idea! Now to the nose powder for inspiration!"
@transbastard: Totally. Matheson put all of his Twilight Zone script writing to good use with that twist ending the movie completely chose to ignore. If the monsters are the real monsters all you have is a shitty flick that irresponsibly promotes use of Bob Marley to children.
@noamjamski: You're not the only one.
The Will Smith thing was a remake of the Omega Man, anyhow, not an attempt to adapt I Am Legend--I don't know why they didn't just call it "Omega Man." I think a vampiresque quasi-faithful version of the book might have done better, anyhow.
@cletar: Yeah, I didn't mind the filmmakers modernizing the setting and plot for the Will Smith film. My issue was that they butchered and jettisoned the spirit and themes of the original work which I thought were very powerful.
At least there was the amazing and faithful Vincent Price version, "the Last Man on Earth."
i repectfully dissagree that a dumbed down niccol story is better than i was legend before i was legend. one could have been something great, the other could never have been anything other than what it was, which makes the former much more depressing than the latter.
In the rewrite, as Manhattan breaks away and drifts across the pond, it's filled with zombie unicorns that the little girl must tame in order to set her father free from... Um... Will Smith.
@Travis Greene: Domesticated cows wouldn't fare that well post-humanity.
@corpore-metal: While that is a valid argument, I'd attribute the popularity of disaster movies to eco-fear. Humanity's fears always show up in movies, just as people's fears always show up in their dreams. We are learning our only real enemy left is ourselves and are hoping we do not destroy the earth as we eventually bring about our own demise.
@psthmn: also it was kind of a giant let down also. Super-creepy first half, enormously shitty CGI villains in the last half, followed by a boringly unsympathetic Will Smith in full on steroid-mode.
And to top it all off, let's make ALTERNATE ENDINGS so that the whole world can see that nobody knew what the fuck they were doing, and this shitty movie was assembled by committee.
Interesting. I read the book a while ago, and really enjoyed it, but I honestly can't see what they can do that The Day After Tomorrow and I Am Legend hasn't done already.
In order for the audience to identify with the story there has to be some sort of character. Be that a survivor, a cute robot, or even some cockroach running around. There has to be a primary point of view character to tell the story with.
07/10/09
07/10/09
I will not pay tpo see any movie with his children in it. No more talentless forced legacy actors.
They shouldn't have touched my beloved Karate Kid.
07/10/09
07/10/09
Was I the only person who thought the I Am Legend film more closely adapted and borrowed ideas from World War Z?
07/10/09
"Here is a book with some cultural staying power, so to make it a success we should remove everything special about it. Another brilliant idea! Now to the nose powder for inspiration!"
07/10/09
07/10/09
The Will Smith thing was a remake of the Omega Man, anyhow, not an attempt to adapt I Am Legend--I don't know why they didn't just call it "Omega Man." I think a vampiresque quasi-faithful version of the book might have done better, anyhow.
07/10/09
At least there was the amazing and faithful Vincent Price version, "the Last Man on Earth."
http://www.amazon.com/Last-Man-Earth-Vincent-Price/dp/B000WC3A0I/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=dvd&qid=1247263472&sr=8-1
07/10/09
07/10/09
07/10/09
07/10/09
07/10/09
07/10/09
07/10/09
07/10/09
07/10/09
04/02/09
04/02/09
04/02/09
04/02/09
A whole movie that just aliens uncovering our archeological leftovers would be fantastic.
04/02/09
You get some visually-appealing bipedal aliens poking around and trying to figure out what happened to us and how we lived and there ya go.
04/02/09
imagine a happy bright future for christs sake.
04/02/09
04/02/09
04/02/09
@corpore-metal: While that is a valid argument, I'd attribute the popularity of disaster movies to eco-fear. Humanity's fears always show up in movies, just as people's fears always show up in their dreams. We are learning our only real enemy left is ourselves and are hoping we do not destroy the earth as we eventually bring about our own demise.
04/02/09
And didn't History Channel or NatGeo already do The World Without Humans? Documentary-style, but still fun.
Honestly, you think they'd get a greenlight for this from Hollywood without a love interest? :)
04/02/09
By an extremely wide margin.
04/02/09
And to top it all off, let's make ALTERNATE ENDINGS so that the whole world can see that nobody knew what the fuck they were doing, and this shitty movie was assembled by committee.
04/02/09
04/02/09
04/02/09
04/02/09
04/02/09
04/02/09
04/02/09
04/02/09
04/02/09
[www.history.com]
Isn't that enough?
04/02/09
04/02/09