i think the rot set in when they made his ship a police box

posts about #ithinktherotsetinwhentheymadehisshipapolicebox more →
When Did Doctor Who Start To Go Downhill?

Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

Dsmvwl Admin Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×

Slatz_Grobnik
01/05/09

In reply to When Did Doctor Who Start To Go Downhill?
Doctor Who is an unusual show. It is almost the exception to the rule that TV programs eventually jump the shark. This is a show that has turned reinvention into the plot of the show itself.
Reply

Slatz_Grobnik was starred Slatz_Grobnik was unstarred

Annalee Newitz
01/05/09

In reply to When Did Doctor Who Start To Go Downhill?
This post is full of win.
Reply

Annalee Newitz was starred Annalee Newitz was unstarred

ShrabanaNizbit
01/05/09

In reply to When Did Doctor Who Start To Go Downhill?
A little late to jump on the Doctor Who wagon, but I'd like to start off now - which new season is the best to start of with?
Reply

ShrabanaNizbit was starred ShrabanaNizbit was unstarred

Charlie Jane Anders
01/05/09

@ShrabanaNizbit: If you've never seen any of it, I would start with the first season (series) of the new show, starring Christopher Eccleston.
Reply

David Rose
01/05/09

In reply to When Did Doctor Who Start To Go Downhill?
You know, for a site that is dedicated to Science Fiction, io9 makes more claims of series being in trouble, or being poorly written than any other site on the internet.

What's especially interesting is that what io9 writes about a particular series isn't necessarily reflected by the viewing public.
Reply

David Rose was starred David Rose was unstarred

Charlie Jane Anders
01/05/09

@David Rose: Wow, you really don't have any sense of humor at all, do you?
Reply

Nicolars
01/05/09

In reply to When Did Doctor Who Start To Go Downhill?
I guess people who like and enjoy the show aren't welcome on this site.
Reply

Nicolars was starred Nicolars was unstarred

92BuickLeSabre
01/05/09

@Nicolars: Nope, just people with no sense of humor.
Reply

92BuickLeSabre was starred 92BuickLeSabre was unstarred

Evil Tortie's Mom: R.O.A.C.H.
01/05/09

@92BuickLeSabre: And the irony-impaired.
Reply

KhaiJB
01/05/09

In reply to When Did Doctor Who Start To Go Downhill?
when did start to go downhill?

when ppl lost perspective and started being obnoxious assholes ranting about what they think is wrong with the show. looking at outpost gallifrey and it's descendants here, not I09.

it's a TV show. one I've loved since birth (literally. Mama Khai used to put me in my bouncy chair infront of the TV cos it was the only thing that would calm me down... my very first memory's are of the Spider jumping onto Sarah-Jane's back and vanishing. wonder why I'm terrified of spiders now..not. ) but I do realise .. it's a TV show. it's not real. and certainly it does not have to inspire the levels of hatred I've seen over the years in forums and newsgroups.

jeeze... if you thought trek fans could be bitchy....
Reply

KhaiJB was starred KhaiJB was unstarred

whatamidoinghere
01/05/09

@KhaiJB: ...

Dude, you just dissed a bunch of fanboys.

You might want to run now.
Reply

whatamidoinghere was starred whatamidoinghere was unstarred

KhaiJB
01/05/09

@whatamidoinghere: and they'll do what? be nasty to me on the internet, saying bad things about me?

skin's thicker than that...
Reply

KhaiJB was starred KhaiJB was unstarred

capntim
01/05/09

In reply to When Did Doctor Who Start To Go Downhill?
there was a no-monsters rule? i thought the daleks showed up in one of the first few serials?
Reply

capntim was starred capntim was unstarred

Charlie Jane Anders
01/05/09

@capntim: There was indeed a no-monsters rule. It lasted a month.
Reply

Little Time Bomb
01/05/09

In reply to When Did Doctor Who Start To Go Downhill?
The show will remain as it always has been...lots of fun.
Reply

Little Time Bomb was starred Little Time Bomb was unstarred

Pope John Peeps II
01/05/09

In reply to When Did Doctor Who Start To Go Downhill?
It all ended when they got a reasonable budget for special effects, which then precluded ever watching a fishy alien mask deflate while leaking green toy sludge.
Reply

Pope John Peeps II was starred

Charlie Jane Anders
01/05/09

@Pope John Peeps II: At first, I read this as "defecate." Which I think did happen a few times in the Colin Baker era.
Reply

Pope John Peeps II
01/05/09

@Charlie Jane Anders: Seriously though, bad effects are charming. Good effects just sort of try too hard sometimes.

Like when that dalek in the new season flew and fired lightning? Come on! The dalek is a trash can with a plunger arm who just happens to want to destroy all life. That's what a dalek should be!

BRING BACK PLUNGER ARM.
Reply

Pope John Peeps II was starred

kipsteele
01/05/09

In reply to When Did Doctor Who Start To Go Downhill?
I'd love it if I could catch old Dr Who somewhere as I'm fascinated by all of the old plot points mentioned. I remember seeing old episodes on PBS back in the days before Tivo. Looks like I will haev to ask the interweb for some help.

IMHO it does not suck and has not jumped the shark. There is no Jar Jar moment as I have seen it.
Reply

kipsteele was starred kipsteele was unstarred

92BuickLeSabre
01/05/09

@kipsteele: If you're not up for all of them, Charlie Jane posted this a while back.

[io9.com]

I've been watching anything available on either Netflix (and a couple of others that are surprisingly on iTunes), which also cuts the viewing down since a lot of old episodes (even ones that aren't "missing") aren't yet on DVD.

Although I'm sure you can "find" them plenty of other places as well.
Reply

92BuickLeSabre was starred 92BuickLeSabre was unstarred

Plague
01/05/09

In reply to When Did Doctor Who Start To Go Downhill?
Was Graeme busy doing something negative on something else?
Reply

Plague was starred Plague was unstarred

JennaW
01/05/09

@Plague: *high-fives*

But I have to say -- this is a very ironic comment, considering the source ;)
Reply

JennaW was starred JennaW was unstarred

Plague
01/05/09

@JennaW:

(doffs cap)
Reply

Plague was starred Plague was unstarred

salviati
01/05/09

In reply to When Did Doctor Who Start To Go Downhill?
I guess I'm a relative new-comer to Doctor Who. I only first came across the show last year, and I have only watched the four 'new' seasons beginning in 2005. I have to say that I have enjoyed the series very much, and I was very disappointed when I finally caught up to the end of the series a few weeks ago.

Now, I think I'll have to find some vintage '60s Doctor to keep me occupied. I really have enjoyed the new series with a few hideous exceptions. I really hope it was as good as you insist, and not just the nostalgia talking.
Reply

salviati was starred salviati was unstarred

92BuickLeSabre
01/05/09

@salviati: Charlie Jane posted this helpful guide for folks in your position a while back.

[io9.com]

But if you're like me and can't help wanting to start from the beginning, I recently coped with the "new shows" lag by starting with the 2nd Doctor and just went from there. I watched the 4th Doctor as a kid, but it still took a bit to get into the old-school effects, but Troughton was so good it made it easier. Plus, so few of the early episodes are on DVD that you can watch all of them and still not have seen so many that it wears out your welcome.

I'm in the final season of the 3rd Doctor now and loving it.
Reply

92BuickLeSabre was starred 92BuickLeSabre was unstarred

RAHfanboy
01/06/09

@salviati: Anything from the Baker/Sladen era is highly recommended, as well, although you will need to deal with the "tin dog."
Reply

RAHfanboy was starred RAHfanboy was unstarred

Andrew Liptak
01/05/09

In reply to When Did Doctor Who Start To Go Downhill?
Torchwood.
Reply

Andrew Liptak was starred Andrew Liptak was unstarred

JohnDeere
01/05/09

In reply to When Did Doctor Who Start To Go Downhill?
i only got into it for Rose. she was hot. couldnt watch after she was gone. but man her new call girl show rocks.
Reply

JohnDeere was starred JohnDeere was unstarred

Plague
01/05/09

@JohnDeere:

oh, thanks for my first big laugh of the new year!
Reply

Plague was starred Plague was unstarred

jccalhoun
01/05/09

@JohnDeere: Was there another Rose besides Rose Tyler because "hot" is never a word I ever thought to use in connection with her?
Reply

jccalhoun was starred jccalhoun was unstarred

Evil Tortie's Mom: R.O.A.C.H.
01/05/09

@jccalhoun: Same here. They missed a chance here by not putting "When the Doctor got a mumbly rodent-toothed peroxided chav companion who KEPT COMING BACK".

Capt. Jack is allowed to do anything (or anyone) or nothing.
Reply

92BuickLeSabre
01/05/09

@Evil Tortie's Mom: I must admit that it is hard to explain to someone who doesn't see it, the impact that the phrase "rodent-toothed peroxided chav companion who KEPT COMING BACK" has on those of us that do.

But let's just say that it certainly doesn't sound like an insult.

"rodent-toothed peroxided chav companion who KEPT COMING BACK"

(Sorry, just had to say it again....)
Reply

92BuickLeSabre was starred 92BuickLeSabre was unstarred

Evil Tortie's Mom: R.O.A.C.H.
01/05/09

@92BuickLeSabre: Dammit, I need to work on my insults, then. Should I have added "repulsive" or "nausea-provoking"?

And you left out "mumbly". But thanks for noticing. :)
Reply

Garrison Dean: R.O.A.C.H.
01/05/09

In reply to When Did Doctor Who Start To Go Downhill?
Honestly, when I was in single digits I couldn't handle it. I know that is sacrilege and I don't mean it as a comment on it's quality, but as a child reared on Star Wars, BSG, Buck Rogers I would hear about Dr. Who, and knew it had spaceships, aliens and robots and then would watch it and see grips shaking around dryer vent tubes added with a lot of talking and couldn't get into it.

So call me shallow but it wasn't until Eccleston and bigger budgets and production values that I got into it.
Reply

92BuickLeSabre
01/05/09

@Grrsn Dn: Shallow.

Seriously, I just watched "The Three Doctors" for the first time yesterday, and it was, quite possibly, the best thing ever.
Reply

92BuickLeSabre was starred 92BuickLeSabre was unstarred

Garrison Dean: R.O.A.C.H.
01/05/09

@92BuickLeSabre: Again, not a statement on quality and I do want to go back and watch the old ones but just don't know where to start or what is the best to do. I'm older and wiser now and can look past shoddy production values to the story beneath.
Reply

92BuickLeSabre
01/05/09

@Grrsn Dn: Did you see this post (that I've been putting in essentially every comment)?

[io9.com]

Although I do think it's worth just watching everything available on DVD. It's still not a lot for the earliest doctors, and Netflix has done me right. (Plus a bunch are available with streaming now.)

Actually I skipped the first doctor, but watching whatever you can with Troughton is worth it.
Reply

92BuickLeSabre was starred 92BuickLeSabre was unstarred

Charlie Jane Anders
01/05/09

@92BuickLeSabre: Thanks for pointing people to that post! Thanks, also, for the "sense of humor" thing. I appreciate it! :)
Reply

Charlie Jane Anders
01/05/09

@92BuickLeSabre: PS: there are a few First Doctor episodes worth watching. Whenever they get the War Machines out on DVD, it's worth taking a look at, I think.
Reply

92BuickLeSabre
01/05/09

@Charlie Jane Anders: I have to admit, watching "The Three Doctors" made me a little sorry that I'd completely skipped Hartnell. I may go back and watch those before I move on to the modern era (for me) with the Fourth.

It was a great post, even though I ultimately ignored it entirely apparently.

(Which leads to my second admission - I kind of love the 6-parters.)
Reply

92BuickLeSabre was starred 92BuickLeSabre was unstarred

Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion

#ithinktherotsetinwhentheymadehisshipapolicebox

io9

SUBSCRIBE TO io9

When Did Doctor Who Start To Go Downhill?

Login

Reset Password

Register

Submit Your Comment