For some reason, io9 editors seemed fixated on the idea that schizophrenia means having multiple personalities. Charlie did the same thing when talking about mentally ill superheroes last week. Schizophrenia is defined as constellation of symptoms including delusions, magical thinking, paranoia and a loss of emotional response. What you're thinking of used to be called multiple personality disorder, now named "dissasociative identity disorder", which really only involves a person believing he or she is more than one person. Mr. Hyde's rather violent personality would be something else entirely; known as antisocial personality disorder, it describes the violent, empathy lacking figures often referred to broadly as "sociopaths" or "psychopaths". None of the three conditions have any relation to each other.
@icelight: Good catch! He might have meant to imply that the studio was schizophrenic for having multiple Jekylls, which would be closer to correct (colloquially, anyway), but Jekyll himself is definitely not schizophrenic.
I'm not sure Keanu can pull it off. He's only really got one dimension to his acting, which works if he's a robot, or a pissed off demon hunter or 'the one' however as someone who would have to pull off two very different characters? Nah. Dr. Jekyll yes, Mr. Hyde? Definitely not.
If anyone on here hasn't see Moffat's Jekyll, it really is recommended. James Nesbitt, who I'm not a big fan of, was utterly compelling as Jekyll and scary as hell as Hyde. Plus Michelle Ryan was in it.
The Moffat version is amazing. I think my only sadness about Moffat getting tapped for Doctor Who showrunner is that it ensures that we will definitely not be getting a second series of Jekyll. Sad face.
@ThisDudeRufus: actually that would be pretty awesome. He was surprisingly creepy in Mr. Brooks, where he played a serial killer. Even though the movie wasn't great, he was really very good and murderous.
I'm not a Keanu hater. I think he's a perfectly workman-like actor. Give him a role and he'll get the job done. But he's not a great actor. Maybe Constantine doesn't require a great actor. Constantine just needs someone who is embittered and cynical as, ah, hell.
That said, I really did not enjoy Constantine the movie. Gave the DVD to a friend immediately after watching it who then donated it to our local library. I suppose if I had never read Hellblazer I might have enjoyed. But I did read it and so the comparisons to the source material was inevitable. And Constantine the movie came up short. Very short.
I think this is why adaptations of comic books always fail. They simply can't live up to the emotional investment I have in the series and characters. The only ones that have worked is Iron Man (who I had no emotional investment in) and Darkman and The Incredibles (which are movies about comic book characters that don't exists so again, no emotional investment).
Final note: my fantasy casting for Constantine would be Rutger Hauer circa 1986, minus the accent.
Interesting, the first one came out around the same time as Sin City, and I always thought it was the better movie, and overlooked because of all the fuss over Sin City's gritty/pretty design.
@Ashimippopotamus Ashis Ashconfused Ashby Ashall Ashthe AshA...: My favorite role of hers, seconded by her stint in The Beach. I prefer to see her doing these types of long shots than her business-suited renditions in Mike Clayton and Burn After Reading.
I loved Constantine, and thought Keanu did a good job. I also recall reading that this was Keanu's favorite movie character, so my hopes are high for a sequel.
@Belabras Told Me To: I dunno. I thought Satan should be cuter. Probably because of the Lucifer comics, but I thought they should have made him creepy/cute not just creepy.
I still think it was pure genius casting to have Gavin Rossdale as Balthazar and Tilda Swinton as Gabriel.
05/10/09
[www.imdb.com]
05/10/09
It saddens me deeply that there are only like three examples of mainstream scifi musicals, and one of them is J&H.
05/10/09
05/10/09
05/10/09
But, seriously, thanks for the correction. Whether it's called MPD or DPD, it'd be nice if people didn't use schizophrenic when they mean MPD/DPD.
DPD: different personalities.
Schizophrenic: voices in your head, etc.
05/10/09
If anyone on here hasn't see Moffat's Jekyll, it really is recommended. James Nesbitt, who I'm not a big fan of, was utterly compelling as Jekyll and scary as hell as Hyde. Plus Michelle Ryan was in it.
05/10/09
05/10/09
05/10/09
Are you kidding? The guy's a master.
Right behind Nic Cage.
05/10/09
05/10/09
04/22/09
04/22/09
That said, I really did not enjoy Constantine the movie. Gave the DVD to a friend immediately after watching it who then donated it to our local library. I suppose if I had never read Hellblazer I might have enjoyed. But I did read it and so the comparisons to the source material was inevitable. And Constantine the movie came up short. Very short.
I think this is why adaptations of comic books always fail. They simply can't live up to the emotional investment I have in the series and characters. The only ones that have worked is Iron Man (who I had no emotional investment in) and Darkman and The Incredibles (which are movies about comic book characters that don't exists so again, no emotional investment).
Final note: my fantasy casting for Constantine would be Rutger Hauer circa 1986, minus the accent.
04/22/09
04/22/09
04/22/09
04/22/09
04/22/09
04/22/09
04/22/09
04/22/09
04/22/09
04/22/09
I still think it was pure genius casting to have Gavin Rossdale as Balthazar and Tilda Swinton as Gabriel.
04/07/09
04/07/09
and i'm with voloxnomad on hesitating to consider the fabric of the rampant and often rabbid anti-Keanury...
04/07/09
04/07/09
04/07/09
04/07/09