kevin macdonald

posts about #kevinmacdonald more →
Last King's Director Rewrites Time In Asimov's Eternity

Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

Dsmvwl Admin Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×

Evil Tortie's Mom: R.O.A.C.H.
04/24/09

In reply to Last King's Director Rewrites Time In Asimov's Eternity
The historical novel that his next film is based on is a Ripping Yarn indeed, although its central premise/big ending turns out to be not true. So it's based on a true-ish story, kinda like George Washington and the cherry tree.
Reply

gorehound
04/24/09

In reply to Last King's Director Rewrites Time In Asimov's Eternity
I own a 1st edition paperback of the end of eternity in vg/fine condition in my scifi library.

We have seen to much YARM coming out and I just keep saying where is Hollywood's brains that they have to remake evry cool film but finally we will have a brand new never before filmed scifi.I am excited and hope it will come out good.

STOP YARM !!!!

MAKE NEW SCIFI's !!!!

thank you for making an original film
Reply

gorehound was starred gorehound was unstarred

John
04/24/09

@gorehound: There's only one story anyway, hero succeeds over antagonist. Who cares if it came from an old book or some hack came up with it on her own?
Reply

John was starred John was unstarred

Evil Tortie's Mom: R.O.A.C.H.
04/24/09

@John: You could say there's three: man vs. man, man vs. nature, man vs. himself.

Or two: protagonist succeeds over antagonist, protagonist fails vs. antagonist.

But it is a small number indeed.
Reply

Grey_Area
04/24/09

In reply to Last King's Director Rewrites Time In Asimov's Eternity
I don't think I've ever read The End of Eternity, better check it out.
Reply

Grey_Area was starred Grey_Area was unstarred

Alasdair Wilkins
04/24/09

@Grey_Area: You won't be disappointed. Unless you are, in which case you have no taste. It's pretty simple, really.
Reply

Alasdair Wilkins was starred Alasdair Wilkins was unstarred

capnrob
04/24/09

@Grey_Area: It's a good story, and certainly lays the groundwork for much of the Time Travel Organization Sub-sub-sub genre, but it's also, as a result, a bit basic seen through modern, genre-savvy eyes. It's kind of like _Voyage of the Space Beagle_ in that respect - after ninety bajillion riffs on Going Boldly Where No Man, Etc., we're not going to be as gobstruck as the audience was at the time of publication, not after, (in Asimov's case) Anderson's Time Patrol, Piper's Paratime, Leiber's Big Time, Chalker's Downtiming the Night Side, etc., etc., etc.

I mention this not because of anything you said, by the way; I am a bit oversensitive on this subject because I've shown people _Casablanca_ and _Duck Soup_, only to have the people completely miss the point that This Is Where These Tropes Came From, Dammit, and say "Well, he's not as funny as Hawkeye Pierce" or whatever. The successor is *not* better than the originator automatically, and it frosts me to hear people assume that it is, merely because they encountered the successor first.

It's probably Asimov's best writing as writing - lord help us, as good as he was in most respects, there's parts of, say, _The Currents of Space_ that make me want to invent a time machine just so I could go back and hand the man a better thesaurus.
Reply

capnrob was starred capnrob was unstarred

Grey_Area
04/24/09

@capnrob: Hmmm. Coming from 1955 this could appear rather dated and yeah, it will suffer comparisons to its descendants. We'll have to hope this can be adapted to appear fresh without losing Asimov's brilliance. Hollywood owes the man that much after that I,Robot dopiness.
Reply

Grey_Area was starred Grey_Area was unstarred

Alasdair Wilkins
04/24/09

In reply to Last King's Director Rewrites Time In Asimov's Eternity
I've got to lay my cards on the table here. Asimov is, as anyone who reads my stuff probably knows at this point, my favorite author of all time, and The End of Eternity is my favorite book of all time, so this might my single most anticipated movie at this point (although I'm a bit saddened I won't get the opportunity to make the movie myself, megalomaniac that I am). The only Kevin MacDonald movie I've seen is Touching the Void, which is a docudrama, so I won't draw too many conclusions. Still, I'm excited.
Reply

Alasdair Wilkins was starred Alasdair Wilkins was unstarred

Alasdair Wilkins
04/24/09

@Alasdair Wilkins: Now if we could only get Roland Emmerich the hell away from the Foundation movies...
Reply

Alasdair Wilkins was starred Alasdair Wilkins was unstarred

Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion

#kevinmacdonald

io9

SUBSCRIBE TO io9

Last King's Director Rewrites Time In Asimov's Eternity

Login

Reset Password

Register

Submit Your Comment