libby - io9

posts about #libby more →
Learn Who Not To Expect In Lost's Final Season
The Drunk Driving Curse Of Lost Examined

Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

Dsmvwl Admin Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×

odinbearded
10/24/09

In reply to Learn Who Not To Expect In Lost's Final Season
I, for one, am OK with this. Yeah, I want the answers. But I would much rather have some unanswered questions than have everything answered with a great deal of half-assery. #lost
Reply

Ghost_in_the_Machine promoted this comment odinbearded was starred odinbearded was unstarred

Ghost_in_the_Machine
10/24/09

@odinbearded: Agreed. Answer the big questions (which they should have good answers for) and leave some hints for the other stuff. The fans are going to debate it all anyway so unanswered questions are better than half-assed answers. #lost
Reply

odinbearded
10/24/09

@Ghost_in_the_Machine: And not every question has to be answered with a philosophical truth bisected by a conspiracy.

Q: "Where did he go for ten minutes???? OMG!!!"

A: He was taking a dump.

Since the creators decided that Libby's nuthouse story would be simple and down-to-earth, I'm glad they didn't force it in. Resolution would be nice, but we've had experience with forced small stories that don't advance the major plotlines.
Reply

Edited by odinbearded at 10/24/09 1:21 PM odinbearded was starred odinbearded was unstarred

ophmarketing
10/24/09

In reply to Learn Who Not To Expect In Lost's Final Season
"Scheduling issues for Mira Furlan"? What else does she have going on? Another straight-to-DVD "Babylon 5" movie? #lost
Reply

theysaidwhat promoted this comment ophmarketing was starred ophmarketing was unstarred

theysaidwhat
10/24/09

@ophmarketing: There was a post from one Furlan's major fans on the Fuselage, years ago, right when Furlan was leaving the show, that indicated she was unhappy filming in HI with the limited use they made of her character. It was promptly removed by the moderators, but there may have been some truth to it. #lost
Reply

theysaidwhat was starred theysaidwhat was unstarred

PVIII
10/24/09

@theysaidwhat: I met her last year at Big Apple Comicon, it seemed to me she felt something similar. #lost
Reply

PVIII was starred PVIII was unstarred

twophrasebark
10/24/09

In reply to Learn Who Not To Expect In Lost's Final Season
I think it would be awesome if the first scene of next season was:

Libby: I think you've all met my father Jacob. #lost
Reply

twophrasebark was starred twophrasebark was unstarred

twophrasebark
10/24/09

(because they've said 900 times that Libby is not coming back) #lost
Reply

twophrasebark was starred twophrasebark was unstarred

mosquitosBuzzz
10/24/09

@twophrasebark: That would be AMAZING! a perfect mindF surprise eh. #lost
Reply

twophrasebark promoted this comment mosquitosBuzzz was starred mosquitosBuzzz was unstarred

Blue_Thark
10/24/09

In reply to Learn Who Not To Expect In Lost's Final Season
To be fair, they've already basically explained what Rousseau's deal was. I feel like her arc has been sufficiently explored. Not a dealbreaker for me, I can live without more Furlan.

On the other hand, if they're doing the whole "what if 815 landed" thing it'll be tough not having a Michael. Let's hope we at least get a final Walt appearance. His connection to the island is one mystery that absolutely needs explaining #lost
Reply

theysaidwhat promoted this comment Blue_Thark was starred Blue_Thark was unstarred

theysaidwhat
10/24/09

@Blue_Thark: Unless they really planned all this out from the first year and pre-filmed Walt scenes for the final season, I don't see how they can show him as though the plane landed. He'd be what, 10 or 11? And now he looks like he's about 25, even though he's probably 17 or 18. #lost
Reply

theysaidwhat was starred theysaidwhat was unstarred

Blue_Thark
10/24/09

@theysaidwhat: I wasn't implying he should appear in the "what if" scenario - without Michael that wouldn't make much sense anyway. But they should bring him back if it continues in the "present" timeline. They've already said they'd be explaining his accelerated growth rate.
Reply

Edited by Blue_Thark at 10/24/09 12:29 PM Blue_Thark was starred Blue_Thark was unstarred

NerD: Blattella
10/24/09

In reply to Learn Who Not To Expect In Lost's Final Season
I guess I am going to be standing in the Hose Jobers line.

We have how many fucking stories about Kate's boring slo-mo story, and you can't get it together to tell one short half an hour explanation of who Libby is?

Remember when they were telling us about how they had a stop date to "Complete the story".

HOSE. JOB. #lost
Reply

NerD: Blattella was starred NerD: Blattella was unstarred

dustin_cahill_pc
10/24/09

@NerD: Blattella: Libby was in the mental asylum because she had a breakdown after losing her husband. That is why she readily gave Desmond her boat. What else needs 'splaining?
Reply

Evil Tortie's Mom: R.O.A.C.H. promoted this comment GreyHammer approved this comment dustin_cahill_pc was starred dustin_cahill_pc was unstarred

GreyHammer
10/24/09

@NerD: Blattella: yeahhh kate is pretty unlikable at this point.

but i dont get what the big deal with libby is. we know she lost her husband and gave desmond his boat. we know she was in hurley's mental hospital. and we know she got shot. thats enough for me. #lost
Reply

GreyHammer was starred GreyHammer was unstarred

krztov
10/24/09

@GreyHammer: her husbands name was dave, thats where she got the boat for desmond, now what was the name of hurleys imaginary friend? dave. that really shouldve been fleshed out more. #lost
Reply

Kpibca promoted this comment krztov was starred krztov was unstarred

TomSkylark
10/24/09

@NerD: Blattella: I think part of the problem is that "LOST" has created really wonderful secondary characters, many of whom don't get enough screen time as the "major players," some of whom just seem like big balls of pathos and boring back stories. Juliet and Sawyer were the exceptions, for me, but, well. I guess one of those isn't going to pan out so well in terms of screen time, right? #lost
Reply

NerD: Blattella promoted this comment TomSkylark was starred TomSkylark was unstarred

Kpibca
10/24/09

@krztov: Don't mistake coincidence for fate. ;) #lost
Reply

Kpibca was starred Kpibca was unstarred

NerD: Blattella
10/24/09

@TomSkylark: Yeah, I know they've written themselves into a corner, and over promised.

I am just so tired of Kate's story, and want to know a little more backstory.

I don't know, I just wish they had made a defined story arc at the beginning and stuck to it. #lost
Reply

NerD: Blattella was starred NerD: Blattella was unstarred

PVIII
10/24/09

In reply to Learn Who Not To Expect In Lost's Final Season
Aw, no Furlan is shame.

Still, the real mystery is why BKV isn't in the writers room this year. I think that could cause a big drop in quality (his episodes were consistently my favorites).

We shall see... #lost
Reply

PVIII was starred PVIII was unstarred

LolaInSlacks
10/24/09

@PVIII: I thought he was developing movies based on his comics and other stuff like that. Like finishing up Ex Machina. #lost
Reply

LolaInSlacks was starred LolaInSlacks was unstarred

Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion

#libby

io9

SUBSCRIBE TO io9

Learn Who Not To Expect In Lost's Final Season

The Drunk Driving Curse Of Lost Examined

Login

Reset Password

Register

Submit Your Comment