Secret invasion review

posts about #secretinvasionreview more →
Marvel's Shapeshifting Aliens Reveal Illusion of Change

Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

Dsmvwl Admin Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×

rek
12/06/08

In reply to Marvel's Shapeshifting Aliens Reveal Illusion of Change
"Marvel's Secret Invasion only offered changes that are cosmetic and temporary."

Again, are you new to comics? That's Standard Operating Procedure.
Reply

rek was starred rek was unstarred

Charlie Jane Anders
12/06/08

@rek: I haven't read a big event comic in over a decade. Actually, no wait, I read Civil War because Graeme gave me his copies. I wouldn't mind a big Event Comic where nothing changes at the end -- but I'm always under the impression that Event Comics are by definition about things changing. Not so much about telling a good story for its own sake. If they did a huge crossover and advertised it by saying "Nothing changes at the end, but it's a fuckin great story!" I would buy it.
Reply

OW-Holmes:Bringer of Fear
12/06/08

In reply to Marvel's Shapeshifting Aliens Reveal Illusion of Change
It would have been great story telling if they killed everyone, the Skrull won, and the Marvel universe just ended.

Eat that status quo!
Reply

EnBuenOra
12/06/08

In reply to Marvel's Shapeshifting Aliens Reveal Illusion of Change
And 'The Death of Superman' was really different in that Superman died, but actually he didn't, but then he came back, and the dude replacing him was just a copy, but when the real one came back he had long hair, and a different costume, but then he went back to the old costume, and cut his hair again.
Reply

EnBuenOra was starred EnBuenOra was unstarred

twophrasebark
12/06/08

@EnBuenOra:

Maybe that really wasn't Superman. And the real real Superman...
Reply

twophrasebark was starred twophrasebark was unstarred

outsdr
12/06/08

@EnBuenOra: The thing is, when Superman died there was never a question of _if_ he would be back- the question was HOW he would come back, and how the characters in his world dealt with this situation.
Reply

outsdr was starred outsdr was unstarred

Balius
12/07/08

@outsdr: So the problem is that in a Marvel book you can imagine something game-changing having a lasting effect, but in DC you expect stagnation from the getgo and aren't disappointed?

Because they sure as heck tried to get you to buy into the "Superman is dead, nothing will ever be the same mentality".
Reply

Balius was starred Balius was unstarred

outsdr
12/10/08

@Balius: "@outsdr: So the problem is that in a Marvel book you can imagine something game-changing having a lasting effect, but in DC you expect stagnation from the getgo and aren't disappointed?"

I'd really appreciate if you could go through my posting and point out exactly what I said that supports your statement, as opposed to assumptions you're making about my opinions.
Reply

outsdr was starred outsdr was unstarred

Earlier threads | All threads | Show hidden threads | Show featured threads only | Start a new discussion

#secretinvasionreview

io9

SUBSCRIBE TO io9

Marvel's Shapeshifting Aliens Reveal Illusion of Change

Login

Reset Password

Register

Submit Your Comment