"The Doctor might be an Emergency Medical Hologram, but he's more than just a bit of hardware." That's because he's not hardware at all. The Emergency Medical Hologram is software stored on Voyager's hard drive. He can also be downloaded into a mobile hologram emitter from the 29th Century.
I agree with the Daleks, black oil, 456, and Vorlons, but the others, while cool, don't really seem to be dirt cheap. I can't imagine the Alien suit being low budget. And the Jem Hadar makeup had to be seriously time consuming. Time being money...
Your comments about Remembrance of the Daleks are a lie! I showed that to a bunch of people as their first Doctor Who. They laughed in Part One and again when the Emperor showed up... but by the time the Special Weapons Dalek made his appearance, they were cheering.
There was an episode of X-Files (I think it was first or second season) where an alien ship crashes, and the military quarantine a whole area because it's semi radioactive, and people keep getting 'radiation burns' when they get too close to the alien/ship. The alien in question has 'masking/invisibility' abilities and so in parts of the show, all you see of the alien is a bending of light near his body. In the "making of the x-files", they show how the effect was done: dressing a guy in bright red jumpsuit, head to toe (kinda like a greenscreen) and having him walk around while they filmed. They just altered the image to make it seem as though the light was bending around an invisible figure. That's cheap, but very very effective. ;)
I don't think I'd count the Daleks on this list; they're really effective in spite of how they look, not because of it. IMHO, they look really silly -- like giant pepper shakers.
@HeartBurnKid: Agent of R.O.A.C.H.: Ok, truth time: I've never seen an episode of Dr. Who. One reason why I've never seen Dr. Who is because every time I see a picture of a Dalek, I just can't take them seriously.
There's a legend that the Vorlon Puppet was so f'ing annoying to work with that when the show was over, the Babylon 5 crew gave it an Office Space style send off. The fiberglass shell was said to have been tied to the back of a truck and dragged around a parking lot, and then attacked with hammers and such.
Brilliant bit Charlie Jane - glad you did this because I have been thinking about this ever since Torchwood : Children of Earth aired. One of the reasons I felt this was among tv's finest was the way the aliens were presented . . . every second the alien was on screen it was terrifying , but there wasn't anything about it that could not have been duplicated by a high-school drama production.
Telling a story compellingly on a tv budget is one of the skills that GOOD television exhibits.
I would also add that much as you, and all of us, tired of the "rubber-forehead-of-the-week" on the Trek incarnations, it is at least a continuing example of the same thing - the story of Trek isn't about monsters, its about the shared "humanity", -for lack of a better word - of all creation. So human-like aliens are the best vehicles for telling that kind of story.
So,despite our ennui, those prosthetics still deserve a place on this list.
The thing is, the original 1963 Daleks were not exactly cheap - they cost about £125 apiece, which is about £1,960 in today's money (or $3,231).
That means they dropped nearly £10,000 in today's money on the four original Dalek props, some of which (or bits of which) were used right up until "Remembrance of the Daleks."
I don't know that I would call the Jem'Hadar "dirt cheap". DS9 had tons of cash. On the flip side, considering the shoestring budget Babylon 5 had, you have to admit the Narns, Drazi, Pak'Ma'Ra, and all the other races they managed to bring to life were doggone impressive, even when compared to shows/films with much larger prosthesis budgets.
Not really alien but a mutant, I'd like to vote for the radioactive liver fluke man from X Files. Low budget man in a rubber suit, but effectively creeped the hell out of me. I have a serious phobia about parasites.
10/08/09
08/21/09
08/21/09
08/21/09
08/21/09
08/23/09
I just imagining this deep growling Dalek voice for him...
08/21/09
08/21/09
08/23/09
08/21/09
08/21/09
08/21/09
Telling a story compellingly on a tv budget is one of the skills that GOOD television exhibits.
I would also add that much as you, and all of us, tired of the "rubber-forehead-of-the-week" on the Trek incarnations, it is at least a continuing example of the same thing - the story of Trek isn't about monsters, its about the shared "humanity", -for lack of a better word - of all creation. So human-like aliens are the best vehicles for telling that kind of story.
So,despite our ennui, those prosthetics still deserve a place on this list.
08/21/09
That means they dropped nearly £10,000 in today's money on the four original Dalek props, some of which (or bits of which) were used right up until "Remembrance of the Daleks."
08/21/09
08/21/09
V, Airwolf, A-Team...
To many mountains to crash behind/into
You want a successful invasion? Do it in the desert.
08/21/09
All opposed say "Nay"................
Motion passed with a landslide victory. The Aye's have it with 100% of the vote.
08/21/09
08/21/09
The CHEAPEST of the cheap aliens has to be the one from "Darkstar".
It was a beachball with feet!