steveguttenberg

posts about #steveguttenberg more →
Which Reboot Would Suck the Most?
Johnny 5 Apparently Still Alive 22 Years Later

Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

Dsmvwl Admin Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×

GodofMonkeys
11/06/09

In reply to Which Reboot Would Suck the Most?
"Yes" should be an option in this poll. That or "all of the above". #cocoon
Reply

GodofMonkeys was starred GodofMonkeys was unstarred

Rumtum
11/05/09

In reply to Which Reboot Would Suck the Most?
I was going to say "Flight of the Phoenix," a Jimmy Stuart tour-de-force that rivals "Twlve Angry Men" and "Lifeboat" for an examination of group dynamics under adversity, but then I remembered it had already been Quaided. So I voted for Mork, because Robin Williams has just gotten too old to do that whole "nanoo nanoo" schtick convincingly.
However, on hindsight, my real choice would be "Yor: Hunter from the Future," because it is such an important piece of cinema and any attempt to redo it would be a travesty. #cocoon
Reply

cletar promoted this comment Rumtum was starred Rumtum was unstarred

Palliard
11/05/09

In reply to Which Reboot Would Suck the Most?
Yet to be mined for YARM: other Krofft properties that aren't Land of the Lost. Ponder the possibilities of movie versions of:

Lidsville
Sigmund the Sea Monster
H. R. Puffnstuff

I especially like the idea of a Lidsville movie, but only as it would be done by Tarantino. #cocoon
Reply

reddingofish promoted this comment Palliard was starred Palliard was unstarred

reddingofish
11/05/09

@Palliard: I would love to see Sigmund the Sea Monster redone but this time by Guillermo Del Toro #cocoon
Reply

reddingofish was starred reddingofish was unstarred

atrus123
11/05/09

In reply to Which Reboot Would Suck the Most?
There's only one movie in this list with Crispin Glover, making my vote easy. The only other film on the list I care a hill-a-beans about is Galaxy Quest, but that one is way to recent for a reboot, so I don't think it will happen anytime soon. I grew up loving Back to the Future though.

I LOVE Max Headroom too, but I'd actually like to see that one remade. I love the original, and I think with an edgy enough director, it could make a killer remake.
Reply

Edited by atrus123 at 11/05/09 4:21 AM atrus123 was starred atrus123 was unstarred

burlybax
11/05/09

@atrus123: There is no replacement for Crispin Glover..

He was the only one that survived the landing procedure, when he arrived from extrasolar planet HD 209458b.. #cocoon
Reply

atrus123 promoted this comment burlybax was starred burlybax was unstarred

Post-Nuked
11/04/09

In reply to Which Reboot Would Suck the Most?
My faith in humanity hangs by a increasingly precarious thread. A Back to the Future remake would sever it completely, I think. #cocoon
Reply

Post-Nuked was starred Post-Nuked was unstarred

cletar
11/04/09

In reply to Which Reboot Would Suck the Most?
The most horrific of all reboots would be to redo "Star Wars," with, say, Shaia LeBoef, or maybe one of the kids from iCarly as Luke, and with the whole thing made to more closely "match" the prequels...including a wacky, older, forgetful Jar-Jar.
Jar-Jar in all six films. #cocoon
Reply

cletar was starred cletar was unstarred

Derek Pegritz
11/04/09

In reply to Which Reboot Would Suck the Most?
Now is the time to remake Max Headroom. The basic concept of a digitized persona bopping around in a hyperconnected, data-drenched age is more relevant today than it was in the 1980s. #cocoon
Reply

Meredith Woerner promoted this comment Derek Pegritz was starred Derek Pegritz was unstarred

atrus123
11/05/09

@Derek Pegritz: I actually agree. Max Headroom is the one movie in the list that I might actually LIKE to see remade. #cocoon
Reply

atrus123 was starred atrus123 was unstarred

TPL2008
11/04/09

In reply to Which Reboot Would Suck the Most?
I was going to add another to the list, Planet of Apes. Then a suppressed memory of the remake came back, back to therapy for me.

BTTF. A trilogy that needs no remake.
Reply

Meredith Woerner promoted this comment Edited by TPL2008 at 11/04/09 7:58 PM TPL2008 was starred TPL2008 was unstarred

TickMan
11/04/09

@TPL2008: At least the remake wasn't as bad as the sequels to the original movie. #cocoon
Reply

Meredith Woerner promoted this comment TickMan was starred TickMan was unstarred

atrus123
11/05/09

@TickMan: Beneath the Planet of the Apes is eons better than Tim Burton's version. The others are about even. #cocoon
Reply

atrus123 was starred atrus123 was unstarred

BlueBeard
11/04/09

In reply to Which Reboot Would Suck the Most?
This is a tough vote to cast- is it the remake that would bother me the most because I liked the original and I'd hate to see it corrupted, or the remake of something awful that will continue to be even more awful? because that list contains both. #cocoon
Reply

BlueBeard was starred BlueBeard was unstarred

reddingofish
11/05/09

@BlueBeard: I voted for ET because our civilization died a little because of that movie and I don't think it could handle that amount of damage a second time. #cocoon
Reply

reddingofish was starred reddingofish was unstarred

collex
11/04/09

In reply to Which Reboot Would Suck the Most?
Hey IO9, you shoud make a "Remake we wouldn't mind thread. Or maybe you already did one. I certainly wouldn't mind a Joss-Whedon directed remake of Frank Oz Little Shop of Horrors (I wanna see Nathan Fillion singing I am a Dentist) #cocoon
Reply

Meredith Woerner promoted this comment collex was starred collex was unstarred

Jrsy Devil's Advocate®
11/04/09

In reply to Which Reboot Would Suck the Most?
Twilight Zone. Yeah, it's not on the list but a few attempts have been made to resurrect it with questionable results. Sometimes you can't capture lighting in a bottle twice.. #cocoon
Reply

David Alvaro
11/05/09

@Jrsy Devil's Advocate®: This is kind of a weird comment. Do you mean the Twilight Zone film? Because that was basically a remake of its own, taking old episodes and stringing them together, and I think somewhat less than perfect. But a new Twilight Zone series, if they could actually get together a collection of talent like they had in the original run, would be awesome. The later attempts at the series were pretty lame, although I remember kind of enjoying the recent remake of "The Monsters are Due on Maple Street". But I think they should go for new stories rather than just revising old ones. But it's been a long time since there was a decent anthology series on television, and there's no reason why it couldn't work, as long as they put a lot of effort into it.

And what the hell is Galaxy Quest doing on this list? A decent movie, but it doesn't seem to mesh with the others listed here. #cocoon
Reply

Jrsy Devil's Advocate® promoted this comment David Alvaro was starred David Alvaro was unstarred

Jrsy Devil's Advocate®
11/05/09

@David Alvaro: No, I was referring to the two previous attempts to revive the series.

[en.wikipedia.org] #cocoon
Reply

collex
11/04/09

In reply to Which Reboot Would Suck the Most?
I would not be against a Gremlin remake, if it was more sequel-ly than remak-y (new character, new situations etc.). As long as the Gremlins are NOT CGI. No chipmunks in my Gremlins!

I don't think you could ever MAKE a BttF remake that works. I mean, it's so linked to a particular era (the 80's and the 50's) that doing a BttF remake would mean completly modernizing the movie so it's about a 2000's kid going into the 80's. Which is so different from BttF that you could call it a new movie instead of a remake. #cocoon
Reply

Bigdamnhero promoted this comment collex was starred collex was unstarred

Bigdamnhero
11/04/09

@collex: That's a really good point. You'd almost have to rewrite the entire series to update it to a different two eras.

I don't doubt, however, somebody in 20+ years will say, "Hey, we should remake BttF!" By then, it might actually be a good idea. #cocoon
Reply

Bigdamnhero was starred Bigdamnhero was unstarred

Dr Emilio Lizardo
11/04/09

In reply to Which Reboot Would Suck the Most?
I don't see "all of the above" as a choice. #cocoon
Reply

Dr Emilio Lizardo was starred

Ronnoc
11/04/09

@Dr Emilio Lizardo: Better yet, 'any movie ever.' #cocoon
Reply

Meredith Woerner promoted this comment Ronnoc was starred Ronnoc was unstarred

Spootythegameguru
11/04/09

In reply to Which Reboot Would Suck the Most?
Short Circuit... no-reassemble. #cocoon
Reply

Meredith Woerner promoted this comment Spootythegameguru was starred

CarrerCrytharis
11/04/09

In reply to Which Reboot Would Suck the Most?
'Back to the Future', because it *doesn't need remaking* -- the original is timeless (pun intended). #cocoon
Reply

Meredith Woerner promoted this comment CarrerCrytharis was starred CarrerCrytharis was unstarred

Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion

#steveguttenberg

io9

SUBSCRIBE TO io9

Which Reboot Would Suck the Most?

Johnny 5 Apparently Still Alive 22 Years Later

Login

Reset Password

Register

Submit Your Comment