Of course it's easier to write about a dystopia than a utopia. Dystopias are eminently believable, while trying to make a utopia seem like there's a chance in hell of it actually working is nigh-impossible.
-Kle. #kimstanleyrobinson
The funny thing about the Thomas More's Utopia is that the whole thing isn't what people think it is. It's very subtly satirical in places, and sometimes menacing. More's Utopia wasn't meant to be prescrptively perfect, but was meant to illustrate certain things about the world at large and human nature. Like Plato's Republic, or Dante's Paradise.
A great utopian fiction also covers all of the problems in society. But intellectually, subtly, subversively. It's not prescriptive except in the way that it teaches you how to look at the subtle currents in society as a whole, and examine the meanings in larger pictures.
Robinson is right that it's harder to do, but he doesn't fully get at why it's so much harder. Which is fair. He's an author, and author's don't study literature. #kimstanleyrobinson
KSR has been getting a little preachy lately but I really like his stuff in general. he seems to be trying to right about how we got to the utopia in all his big works (Mars, 40/50/60, Rice and Salt) and that can certainly be an interesting story. #kimstanleyrobinson
Most science fiction I've read doesn't necessarily take place in a dystopia or a utopia but in some form of society that is pretty much somewhere in between.
Also there are science fiction stories where one civilization has spread out to include many cities, planets, or colonies where some are virtually utopias while others are very much dystopian factory worlds.
Also, a lot of stories I've read about utopian societies often suggest that there is something terribly wrong with the utopia at it's secret inner core or the author portrays a world where somehow people are no longer responsible for their own well being while still somehow retaining a great degree of personal freedom and growth while having almost no external challenges to overcome whatsoever. I think it'd be great if humanity could be so greatly self motivated but I imagine in such a world we'd look a lot like the fat people in WALL·E .
@strideo: Also, a lot of stories I've read about utopian societies often suggest that there is something terribly wrong with the utopia at it's secret inner core
I'm not trying to be snide here, but those are actually dystopian stories. They illustrate the abject failure of a utopian project. #kimstanleyrobinson
Another thing occurred to me though; not everyone's utopia would be the same now would it? What may seem like a blissful society to some may be felt as stifling and oppressive to others. #kimstanleyrobinson
@strideo: Well okay... I don't want to get into very elementary things about utopian fiction because we'll be here all day.
But in broad terms, Utopian fiction is a type of fiction in which although the project seems largely successful, underlying tensions and currents in the story and in the people involved reveal difficulties, fragilities, even subtle tyrannies in the structure. No Utopia is perfect. As a classical scholar More knew this well when he named his book. In Greek u topos means both "perfect place" and "no place". It's still a "good" place, but where you find difficulties in that "goodness" is where thought is provoked.
A dystopian book is the chronicle of the total failure of that kind project. An outright tyranny, or a miserable population, or one chemically controlled, etc. etc. #kimstanleyrobinson
While I count myself as a huge fan of the Mars Trilogy, the unfortunate truth is that every time KSR decided to write about his "utopia" in the novels, it descended into unreadable pseudo-eco-socialist blathering nonsense that detracted from what was otherwise a fantastic yarn.
I won't take my sci-fi from my economists if I can avoid taking economics from my sci-fi authors. #kimstanleyrobinson
@Daveinva: Funny, I had the total opposite reaction. I loved the times when he talked economics and politics--the parts about the struggle to create a utopia--and was bored to tears by the endless textbook-like descriptions of Martian geology and botany. I still have yet to finish Blue Mars as a result.
Don't get me wrong; science is cool, geology is cool, but at the end of the day, rocks are just rocks, and the challenge of creating a better society is much more interesting. #kimstanleyrobinson
@Anekanta - Space Hippy!: To each their own. I was a poli sci major, I already had my fill of bad philosophy and econ by the time I read the books, I ate up the science stuff instead.
I mean, come on: SPACE. ELEVATOR. WRAPPING. AROUND. MARS.
@Daveinva: I loved that! That's what I mean though--the falling space elevator and the politics that led up to it was way more interesting than the dry explanations of which species of lichen would be likely to survive on the Martian surface.
It wasn't that I found his political or economic explanations any more interesting. It was more the human interactions involved--the different motivations behind the political and economic discussions--that I found appealing.
@Pegritz: Yeah, if only because it sounds a little insane, or very insane. It depends on whether it is written half-seriously, or completely serious. Half-serious, it could go either way. Completely serious... it's comedy gold. Like Dr. Bronners All-in-one soap.
It's just as fantastical as the idea of somebody like Tony Stark or Bruce Wayne becoming a selfless hero.
Nothing would thrill me more than to have the power of the wealthy elite on our side. But i think i have a better chance of pulling myself inside-out first.
@Aidan_: To be fair though, both guys suffered horrendous trauma which inspired their altruism
Also the Waynes were philanthropic saints to begin with and made sure to instill their philosophy and virtues into their son from the very beginning.
Tony Stark is usually shown as a privileged asshole playboy stereotype + genius before his kidnapping, torture, and interaction with war victims (and sometimes afterwards too).
11/10/09
-Kle. #kimstanleyrobinson
11/10/09
A great utopian fiction also covers all of the problems in society. But intellectually, subtly, subversively. It's not prescriptive except in the way that it teaches you how to look at the subtle currents in society as a whole, and examine the meanings in larger pictures.
Robinson is right that it's harder to do, but he doesn't fully get at why it's so much harder. Which is fair. He's an author, and author's don't study literature. #kimstanleyrobinson
11/09/09
11/09/09
+1, Kim. #kimstanleyrobinson
11/09/09
11/09/09
Also there are science fiction stories where one civilization has spread out to include many cities, planets, or colonies where some are virtually utopias while others are very much dystopian factory worlds.
Also, a lot of stories I've read about utopian societies often suggest that there is something terribly wrong with the utopia at it's secret inner core or the author portrays a world where somehow people are no longer responsible for their own well being while still somehow retaining a great degree of personal freedom and growth while having almost no external challenges to overcome whatsoever. I think it'd be great if humanity could be so greatly self motivated but I imagine in such a world we'd look a lot like the fat people in WALL·E .
11/10/09
I'm not trying to be snide here, but those are actually dystopian stories. They illustrate the abject failure of a utopian project. #kimstanleyrobinson
11/10/09
Another thing occurred to me though; not everyone's utopia would be the same now would it? What may seem like a blissful society to some may be felt as stifling and oppressive to others. #kimstanleyrobinson
11/10/09
But in broad terms, Utopian fiction is a type of fiction in which although the project seems largely successful, underlying tensions and currents in the story and in the people involved reveal difficulties, fragilities, even subtle tyrannies in the structure. No Utopia is perfect. As a classical scholar More knew this well when he named his book. In Greek u topos means both "perfect place" and "no place". It's still a "good" place, but where you find difficulties in that "goodness" is where thought is provoked.
A dystopian book is the chronicle of the total failure of that kind project. An outright tyranny, or a miserable population, or one chemically controlled, etc. etc. #kimstanleyrobinson
11/09/09
11/09/09
I won't take my sci-fi from my economists if I can avoid taking economics from my sci-fi authors. #kimstanleyrobinson
11/09/09
Don't get me wrong; science is cool, geology is cool, but at the end of the day, rocks are just rocks, and the challenge of creating a better society is much more interesting. #kimstanleyrobinson
11/09/09
I mean, come on: SPACE. ELEVATOR. WRAPPING. AROUND. MARS.
And you like the econ???
;-) #kimstanleyrobinson
11/09/09
It wasn't that I found his political or economic explanations any more interesting. It was more the human interactions involved--the different motivations behind the political and economic discussions--that I found appealing.
Not sure I'm making sense, but...
:D #kimstanleyrobinson
11/09/09
WOOOOHOOOOOO YAY SPACESHIPS #kimstanleyrobinson
11/09/09
11/09/09
Count me in.
09/24/09
-Kle.
09/22/09
09/22/09
09/22/09
Nothing would thrill me more than to have the power of the wealthy elite on our side. But i think i have a better chance of pulling myself inside-out first.
09/22/09
Also the Waynes were philanthropic saints to begin with and made sure to instill their philosophy and virtues into their son from the very beginning.
Tony Stark is usually shown as a privileged asshole playboy stereotype + genius before his kidnapping, torture, and interaction with war victims (and sometimes afterwards too).
09/22/09
09/22/09
Maybe all the characters munch on baby carrots instead of constantly lighting up cigarettes.
09/22/09
09/22/09
09/22/09