I respect Annalee's opinions and I'm sure she's researched this more than I have. Furthermore, I didn't RTFA so I may be way off base.
But...
Don't we see those two extremes in good times as well as bad? Aren't they simply the two easiest extreme mirrors to hold up and examine ourselves?
Star Trek movies have been released every 2 - 3 years for 30 years, the terminator movies came out in '84, '91 and '03. The last, at least, was during good econimic times, I'd have to research the other two.
Also, given the times required for a production cycle, do movies really reflect exclusively the time they are released? Both these movies were in production well before the current financial situation.
@DrEmilioLizardo: I always thought Minority Report depicted the most realistic future. Neither uptopia or distopia, just today, but with more shiny things.
@DrEmilioLizardo: Of course a lot of this depends on how you define "dark times." As to whether SF always depicts extremes - I wouldn't say that. There's plenty of SF that shows us a future that's a mix of good and bad. However, I definitely don't think there's an iron-clad rule that says only turbulent times produce utopian/dystopian splits. What I was trying to get at in this article was more about what kinds of issues each era was arguing over in their utopian/dystopian stories - whether the human future would be wealthy, whether our technology would destroy us, whether we'd survive.
Excellent stuff recently from these four. I know a few of these people personally and count them as friends. Some of them do not care for the term "Small Press" and would prefer to be called Independent Publishing Houses.
But that's just the sort of thing you'd expect from someone at a teeny-tiny cute little company like that.
01/05/09
01/05/09
01/04/09
01/05/09
01/04/09
But...
Don't we see those two extremes in good times as well as bad? Aren't they simply the two easiest extreme mirrors to hold up and examine ourselves?
Star Trek movies have been released every 2 - 3 years for 30 years, the terminator movies came out in '84, '91 and '03. The last, at least, was during good econimic times, I'd have to research the other two.
Also, given the times required for a production cycle, do movies really reflect exclusively the time they are released? Both these movies were in production well before the current financial situation.
01/05/09
01/05/09
I think that maybe makes it count as a dystopia.
01/05/09
01/04/09
01/04/09
01/04/09
Also, it's wildly optimistic as to progress. It's the usual "stuff just around the corner" that's been around that corner for half a century.
01/04/09
12/22/08
But that's just the sort of thing you'd expect from someone at a teeny-tiny cute little company like that.
12/22/08